Use Dehooking Tools in the Right Depth Order

A hook comes out cleanly on a lip hold and badly on a swallowed one, and the difference is decided in the first minute. Every second a fish spends out of the water adds to an oxygen debt it must repay after release. On a jetty, a beach or a boat, the tools within reach determine whether that minute goes into removing a hook or into fumbling for one.

fish handlingDifficulty 2/5
Cover illustration: Use Dehooking Tools in the Right Depth Order

Key facts

Key factDetail
Air exposure targetUnder 60 seconds from lift to return
Handling limitUnder 20 seconds when a photograph is taken
Deep-hook decisionCut the line when the bend cannot be seen or felt
Barotrauma depthFish from deeper than 30 feet can need recompression
Hook typeBarbless or crimped barbs come out fastest
Kit sizeFour tools cover pliers, forceps, disgorger and cutters

What each tool reaches

Carry four items: long-nosed pliers, forceps, a disgorger and line cutters. The decision they support is simple. Reach for the tool that matches the hook's depth, and cut the line when no tool can reach the bend without tearing tissue. Long-nosed pliers are the default. They grip the bend or the shank of a single hook without putting fingers near the point, and narrow jaws enter a lip hold on a fish of a pound or two. Forceps do the same job with a longer, thinner reach, which suits a hook just inside the jaw of a larger fish. A disgorger is a slotted or forked rod that slides down the line to the bend. Line cutters are the fourth tool, and the only one that solves a hook no other tool can reach. Reach is the variable that decides the choice. A tool has to arrive at the bend with room to rotate it, not merely touch the point. Pliers on a hook three inches down a throat cannot open their jaws. Forceps can, and a disgorger follows the line further still. Match the tool to the depth before the fish is on the mat, because a search through a bag costs more air exposure than the removal itself.

Why the first minute decides survival

Air exposure is acute hypoxia. The gill filaments stick together and the lamellae, where gas exchange happens, collapse. Aerobic respiration stops, an oxygen debt builds, and carbon dioxide and lactic acid push blood pH down. Heart rate slows while the fish is dry and overshoots when it returns to water. Recovery time lengthens with the time spent out of water, so a removal that takes 15 seconds costs far less than one that takes a minute. NOAA Fisheries sets 60 seconds as the outer limit on air exposure and 20 seconds as the target when a photograph is part of the release. A fish that has already fought hard arrives with lactate in the muscle, and air exposure adds to that load instead of starting from rest. Ten seconds is not automatically safe either. Atlantic salmon exposed to air for up to 10 seconds produced half as many offspring as fish kept wet, which is the strongest argument for the shortest removal that works.

The removal sequence

Start with the fish in the water. Unhook over the side or in the shallows whenever the hook is visible and the fish is calm. Lift only when the hold is deep or the fish is too active to control, and wet both hands before touching it. A dry hand strips the mucus layer that protects the skin from infection. Once the fish is controlled, identify the hook before pulling. Look for the eye, the shank, the bend and every point. On a single hook, grip the bend with pliers and rotate the hook back along the path it entered. Pulling across the lip widens the wound and tears the jaw. If the hook will not rotate, stop and reassess depth instead of increasing force. Keep the fish horizontal and supported along its length. A fish held vertically by the jaw or the lip puts its organs against gravity, and the jaw is not a handle. Texas Parks and Wildlife draws the line at 5 pounds: smaller fish can be held by the lower jaw, larger ones need a hand under the belly and one at the tail. The whole sequence has a budget of about 20 seconds if a photograph follows.

Pliers, forceps and the disgorger

The disgorger earns its place on a hook that has gone past the lip but not into the gut. Slide it down the line until the slot meets the bend, engage the bend, and push down and back to rotate the hook out. The line is the guide, so keep it tensioned. A disgorger used blind, jabbing at the throat, drives the point deeper and tears the tissue it passes. Forceps work on the same principle with a shorter reach and a firmer grip. They are the better tool when the hook sits just inside the jaw of a fish with a large mouth, where pliers cannot open. Neither tool should be forced. If the bend cannot be seen or felt, the hook is beyond the reach of both, and the cutters become the correct tool. A hook-out is a short handle with a forked or notched tip, sold for freshwater plugs. It works by pushing against the bend, so it needs a straight path and a hook that is already loose. On a large saltwater hook the notch slips, and on a deep hook the handle is too short to reach. Treat it as a third hand for easy lip hooks, not as a substitute for forceps. The holding hand matters as much as the removing hand. A wet rubber glove gives grip on a fish that is still moving and keeps fingers away from the point. The other hand works the pliers. Two dry hands on a wet fish is the combination that ends with a hook in a thumb, and a hook in a thumb ends the session. A disgorger also has a length limit. The tool has to be longer than the hook's path into the mouth, or it arrives at the line and stops short of the bend. Check that against the hooks actually used. A disgorger sold for small freshwater hooks is decoration in a saltwater kit, and a short tool on a deep hook is worse than no tool.

When to cut the line

A deep hook is the case for cutters. Cut the line as close to the hook as the cutters will reach, leaving the shortest possible tag. A long tag catches on weed and on the fish's own movements. Do not cut the hook point off and leave the shank; a barbed fragment with no eye has no way out, and no way to work loose. Cutting feels like failure and is the correct move whenever the bend cannot be reached without tearing tissue. Pulling a gut-hooked hook out drags the point and the barb through tissue that will not heal before the fish is released. A hook left in place has a chance of working loose or corroding. Non-stainless hooks corrode in salt water, which is one reason NOAA Fisheries recommends them for catch and release. Stainless hooks can stay in place for years. That difference changes the decision by hook type. A high-carbon hook in a gut hold is a case for cutting and releasing. The same hold with a stainless hook leaves a hook that will not disappear, so the odds are worse, but tearing it out is still the worse option. Cut, release, and accept the loss of a hook that costs less than the fish.

Treble hooks and multi-point lures

A treble multiplies the problem. Two or three points can be embedded at once, and pulling the body of the lure loads all of them. Cut the lure free first so the fish is not attached to a heavy object, then deal with one point at a time. Back out the point that is clearly visible; cut off any point that cannot be backed out without tearing. Replacements reduce the problem before it starts. A single hook in place of a treble, or one treble instead of two on a lure, leaves fewer points to remove. Barbless points and crimped barbs come out faster and make a hook that is already set easier to reverse. A pair of pliers flattens a barb in a second, and that second is repaid at the first deep hook. The exception is a fish that is bleeding from a gill or a throat. More pulling makes that worse. Cut the line, leave the hook, and get the fish back in the water. A hook in a bleeding fish is a smaller problem than the handling needed to remove it, and the bleeding fish has less time to spare, because the hook is not the emergency.

Deep water adds barotrauma

A fish pulled from deeper than 30 feet can arrive with barotrauma even when the hook comes out perfectly. Gas in the swim bladder expands as pressure falls, and the fish may show bulging eyes, a bloated belly or a stomach protruding from the mouth. Those fish cannot swim back down on their own, and releasing one at the surface is not a release. A descending device returns the fish to the depth it came from and recompresses the gas. Venting with a proper tool is a second option. A knife is the wrong tool, because puncturing the stomach or the gut causes injuries the fish does not recover from. The kit for deep water includes a descender alongside the pliers, and both fit in one pocket. The dehooking decision changes with depth as well. A fish from 30 feet or more has already paid a pressure penalty on the way up, so the air exposure budget is shorter. Unhook it at the surface if the hook is accessible, and send it back down with the descender in the same motion. Do not measure it, photograph it and then decide.

The kit check before the trip

Test the tools before a fish needs them. Cutters should sever the heaviest line on the outfit, braid included, in one squeeze; a cutter that needs two bites crushes rather than cuts. Pliers should open wide enough to span the bend of the largest hook carried and should grip without slipping. Forceps need straight tips that meet and do not cross under pressure. Check the reach against the hooks actually used. Carry the tools on a lanyard or in a pocket that opens with one hand, because the moment a hook is set is the worst time to search. Replace cutters when the blades nick, wipe pliers dry after salt water, and keep a spare set of cutters in the bag. The spare is for the day the first pair goes over the side.

Related reading

Hook sizes that limit deep hooking When to strike Fewer-hook rigs Bite detection floats Landing before unhooking Fight pressure

Sources

  1. Catch and Release Fishing Best Practices — NOAA Fisheries · T1
  2. Catch & Release Tips — Texas Parks and Wildlife Department · T1
  3. Catch and Release — NOAA Office of National Marine Sanctuaries · T1
  4. Fish Out of Water: How Much Air Is Too Much? — Fisheries (American Fisheries Society) · T2
  5. California Recreational Rockfish Information: Barotrauma and Descending Devices — NOAA Fisheries · T1