Ray and Shark Release: Tail, Gills and the Shore

A ray or a shark landed in the surf or beside a boat is injured by the same mistake: lifting or dragging a body that water is built to support. A shark has cartilage instead of bone, and its organs hang from connective tissue that tears when the tail carries the load. A ray carries a barbed spine on the tail, so the end that looks like a handle is the end that injures the angler.

fish handlingDifficulty 2/5
Cover illustration: Ray and Shark Release: Tail, Gills and the Shore

Key facts

Key factDetail
Air exposure limit60 seconds
Tail liftTears the tissue that holds the organs
Ray spineOn the tail, venomous in many species
Grip scale maximum60 lb
Hook cutAs close to the eye as the cutters reach
Release directionHead into the current
Beach surfaceWet sand or water, never dry sand
GaffNot used on a fish that will be released

Two risk zones: the tail and the mouth

The problem shows up on bay flats, ocean beaches, piers and small-boat decks, anywhere a fish is brought within reach. The decision this calls for is narrow: control the animal in water, support it along its length, and cut the leader rather than lift. A ray's defensive equipment sits at the back. The barb is a sharp spine at the base of a long tail, and in many species it carries venom. A person who steps on a ray in shallow water triggers a reflex that drives the tail up and forward, which is why stings usually land on a foot or a lower leg. The danger zone is the arc the tail can sweep, and it grows with the size of the animal. Stay forward of the disc, and never step over the tail to reach a leader. A shark's danger zone is the other end. Teeth sit at the front, and a hooked shark can swing its head through a wide arc while the body is still. The tail is dangerous as a moving mass rather than a blade. Approach from behind the head only when the animal is already controlled, and keep hands away from the mouth, the gill slits and the eyes. A shark that is still thrashing has not been restrained enough to touch. Identification comes before any of this. A protected species is released where it is, without a lift, a measurement or a photograph. Several sharks that cannot be kept look much like legal species at a glance, and a ray on the bottom shows little more than a outline. If the animal cannot be named with confidence from the water, cut the leader and let it go.

What the body loses out of water

A shark has cartilage instead of bone and no rib cage to carry the weight of its organs. Those organs are held in place by connective tissue that water normally supports. Lift the animal by the tail and the whole mass hangs from that tissue, which can tear and displace what it holds. A ray's disc has the same problem in a different shape: out of the water, the wide body collapses under its own weight and the gills can close against the sand. Sixty seconds is the working limit for air exposure. A fish that is unhooked, measured, photographed and then released has usually spent longer than that above the surface, and the cost is paid after it swims away. The rule on a beach or a boat is the same: if the gills are not in water, the animal is being held rather than handled. Cut the leader and let the water take the weight. Warm shallow water holds less oxygen, and a long fight leaves a shark or ray with less reserve to spend on handling. That combination shortens the useful release window. A fish that has been fought to exhaustion, then laid on hot sand for a photograph, has already used most of its margin before the hook comes out. Shorten the fight with tackle that can turn the animal, and shorten the handling to match.

Shore, boat and surf positions

On a beach, stand in water deep enough to cover the gills and shallow enough to reach the leader. On a gentle sand beach that depth is usually around knee level, and it moves with the tide. Keep the animal horizontal in front of you, not between your legs, and keep your feet still. A ray lying on the bottom is easy to lose track of when the wash clouds the water, so watch the tail while you work. Surf changes the plan. A ray or shark pushed onto wet sand should be eased back with the next surge, not dragged up the dry slope. A shark pulled across dry sand or a sun-heated deck loses skin and the mucus layer that protects it from infection. Set the release point before the fish is landed, and pick a spot where the water drains rather than the steep, dry edge. A boat adds two tools and removes one. A landing sling or a rubber-mesh net carries the body without squeezing it, and a sling can be lowered back over the side with the animal still supported. The gaff comes off the list for any fish that will be released, because the wound it makes does not close. Keep the animal beside the hull, in the shade if there is any, and work with the leader short. A pier and a rocky ledge share a single hazard: height. Lower the animal in a net or on the leader with a second person taking the weight, and never drop it over the rail. On rocks, kneel and reach down so the fish enters water instead of falling into it. The release point is part of the plan, not something to find after the fish is already out of the water and the camera is out.

Supporting the body instead of the tail

Support means two contact points and a level body. Put one hand under the pectoral fins and the other under the belly near the tail base, then lift only enough to keep the animal off the bottom. Keep the shark horizontal. A shark longer than your reach, or heavier than the gear you carry, stays in the water and is released at the leader. There is no photograph worth a torn organ. A ray is handled from the front of the disc, with both hands under the leading edge and the tail left alone. Never use the tail as a handle, even on a small ray, because the spine is attached there and the tail can fold back toward a wrist. A wet towel over the disc can settle a small animal, but the cloth does not protect the hand from the barb underneath it. A sandbar shark is measured inside a sling that carries the body along its length; without a sling, skip the measurement. Photo: NOAA Fisheries, public domain. A scale is not a handle. BogaGrip's largest model is rated to 60 lb and reads in half-pound increments, which makes it a weighing tool for fish that can be lifted safely in the first place. Hanging a shark from a lip grip puts the load on the jaw and the tissue behind it. Weigh the fish only when the body is supported in a sling, and skip the weight when the animal is near or over the rating. People are part of the release. A crowd closes the path between the animal and deep water, and a released shark needs that path open. Ask bystanders to stand back before the leader comes out of the water, and keep dogs away from a ray on the sand. A camera held at arm's length over a shark invites a step closer than the animal can tolerate.

Hook handling and the cut point

Work the hook in the water with a dehooker, long-nose pliers or side cutters. Back the hook out the way it went in, and stop when the bend catches on tissue. A hook that has passed the jaw and reached the throat will not come back through the same hole without damage. Cut the leader as close to the hook eye as the cutters reach, and leave the rest of the hook where it sits. Heavy hooks need heavy cutters. Bolt cutters take a hook apart at the bend so the sections can be backed out, and they also cut a leader that side cutters cannot. Do not jerk or pop a leader to break it, because the load travels straight into the animal. Non-stainless hooks rust through and work loose over weeks, which is why a cut leader beats a torn mouth or a broken jaw. Hook choice changes how often the cutters are needed. Circle hooks tend to catch in the corner of the mouth, and barbless or crimped-barb hooks back out with less force. Both reduce the time an animal spends out of the water, and both make a release possible without a second pair of hands. Carry the cutters on a lanyard at the hip, not in a bag under the seat.

Release direction and the 60-second clock

Point the animal's head into the current and let water enter the mouth and pass out through the gill openings. If there is no current, move the fish forward in a slow figure-eight, never backward. A shark pushed tail-first gets no flow across the gills, and the tail is the last part to hold. Keep the gills under the surface through the whole release, including any photograph. The clock starts when the animal leaves the water and stops when the head goes back in. Sixty seconds is the limit for air exposure, and a release that runs longer has already cost the fish something. A calm shark can be photographed with the lens at the surface and the body below it. A shark that is thrashing goes back without a picture, and the same rule covers a ray that will not settle. Watch the animal after it leaves your hands. A ray that lands on its back and cannot right itself, or a shark that rolls and drifts into the wash, needs to be recovered and held again. Recovering a released fish is allowed, and leaving it to drift is the worse choice. Give it water over the gills until it holds itself upright, then step back and let it swim.

Cases that require cutting the line

The hook sits in the gill arch, the throat or the gut. A ray is hooked under the disc where the mouth cannot be reached without lifting it. The animal is heavier than the 60 lb grip or longer than the sling. The species is protected, so there is no measure, no photograph and no lift. The hook is through the jaw and the teeth sit between your hand and the bend. Surf or a crowded beach leaves no safe place to kneel beside the animal. In each case, cut close to the hook, leave the metal in place and let the animal go. A hook left in a shark or ray is a better outcome than a torn gill arch or a hand injury. The cut end of the leader is short enough that it will not snag on the bottom, and a non-stainless hook will corrode. There is no version of this release that improves with a longer look. Before the next trip, test the cutters on a scrap of the heaviest leader in the bag. One squeeze should sever it cleanly; if the jaw marks the line without cutting through, the tool is too small for the fish you expect. Put the cutters, a wet towel and the sling in the same box, and leave the tape measure there when the sling stays home.

Sources

  1. Catch and Release Fishing Best Practices — NOAA Fisheries · T1
  2. Tagging Instructions and Resources for Volunteers — NOAA Fisheries · T1
  3. Catch and Release Techniques for Sharks — Texas Parks and Wildlife Department · T1
  4. Be Nature Safe: Fish — Texas Parks and Wildlife Department · T1
  5. BogaGrip Model 260 — Eastaboga Tackle Manufacturing · T2