Toothy Fish Handling: Pliers, Gloves and the Cut Line

A bluefish at the rail is a jaw with a fish attached. Its teeth shear instead of grip, so the pliers that work on a bass lip put your knuckles at the cutting edge. The order of work decides the outcome. Control the body first, keep the working hand behind the jaw hinge, and let a tool cross the lip.

fish handlingDifficulty 2/5
Cover illustration: Toothy Fish Handling: Pliers, Gloves and the Cut Line

Key facts

Key factDetail
Pliers length20 cm minimum; 25 cm from a boat
Hand positionBehind the jaw hinge or behind the gill cover
Glove standardANSI/ISEA 105, level A4 or higher
Cut length2 to 3 cm above the hook eye
Two-hand weightFish above 3 kg
Air exposureUnder 60 seconds

Where the teeth sit on the three main groups

The same sequence holds for barracuda and Spanish mackerel landed from a pier, a jetty or a boat in warm water, where the fish is still strong when it reaches the deck. The decision it supports is where the hands go and when the leader gets cut. Bluefish carry razor-sharp teeth and shearing jaws that let them take large pieces of prey. Adults reach 31 pounds and 39 inches. A tooth that slices bait also slices a finger, and it abrades monofilament where the line crosses the jaw. The danger is not one clean bite. A bluefish clamps and shakes, so anything inside the mouth is caught between two blades that close like tin snips. Barracuda carry long canines built for seizing a baitfish crosswise, and they strike at speed, often close to the boat or the pier. A hand reaching for a hook inside that mouth meets a row of points before it meets the bend. Spanish mackerel are smaller, about 13 pounds at the top of the range, with fine teeth that rake skin rather than cut it cleanly. The rake still opens a hand. Tooth shape sets the response. Shearing teeth remove tissue, canines puncture, fine teeth abrade. In each case the working end of the fish is the mouth, and the hand has no business there. Everything that follows is a way to keep that boundary while still removing a hook within the time the fish can afford out of water. Line damage shows before the hook comes out. Run a thumb and forefinger up the first 30 centimetres of leader after every toothy fish, and again after a fish that took the bait deep. Teeth leave a rough patch that feels like a scratch on glass, and that patch is where the next fish breaks off. Cut back to clean line rather than retying on a weakened section. The three groups also arrive differently. A bluefish comes over the rail in a net, still snapping. A barracuda often hangs motionless beside the boat until it sees movement. A Spanish mackerel comes in thrashing and sheds scales across the deck, which makes both the fish and the deck slippery. The landing method has to match the behaviour, not the species list.

Three rules that keep hands out of the tooth zone

Three rules cover every toothy fish handled from shore or boat. They are stated as limits because a grip technique that depends on the fish holding still fails at the moment it matters. The hand stops at the jaw hinge. Thumb and forefinger straddle the mandible from behind, and neither passes the lip line. A tool crosses the tooth line. Pliers, forceps or a jaw spreader goes where fingers would otherwise go. If the bend is not visible from outside the jaw, the leader is cut. No search follows, and no finger goes in for a second look. Each rule removes one failure mode. The first keeps fingers out when the fish is still and the hook sits at the lip. The second keeps them out when the hook is deeper but the bend is visible. The third keeps them out when neither condition holds. A glove changes the consequence of a mistake. It does not change the rule. The rules also set the order of work. Secure the body, identify the hook, choose the tool, then act once. Reversing that order is how fingers end up in a mouth: the hand goes in to hold the fish still, and the pliers arrive afterwards. A fish held by the jaw is a fish whose mouth is already occupied by a hand. The hinge is easy to find on a fish lying flat. Run a fingertip along the lower jaw from the chin toward the back until the bone ends and the jaw drops; that corner is the stop line. On a barracuda the corner is long and easy to overrun. On a bluefish the jaw is short and the hinge sits close to the eye, which leaves little margin for a thumb that slides forward.

Pliers length and the angle of removal

Twenty centimetres of long-nose pliers is the working minimum on a toothy fish. Twenty-five centimetres is better from a boat rail, where the fish is held at arm's length and the deck moves. Shorter pliers put the knuckles at the lip line, which is the one place the hand cannot be. The jaws must close around the bend of the largest hook you carry, with the handles still clear of the lip. Take hold of the bend itself and reverse the hook through the channel it cut. Pressure along that channel lets the wound close behind the point. Sideways force enlarges the puncture and hauls the barb through tissue with no time to heal before release. A rod tip is not a removal tool. Snapping a taut leader drives the point deeper or rips the jaw, and a torn jaw on a released fish is a slow death. A jaw spreader earns its place on barracuda and large bluefish. It holds the mouth open so the pliers can enter without a second hand at the jaw, and it keeps the tooth line visible. A spreader that slips is worse than none, so fit it before the fish is on the deck and keep one hand on the body while the other works. Reach is not the same as control. A long tool can touch a hook that it cannot rotate, because the jaws need room to open around the bend. If the pliers arrive at the hook and the handles are still outside the mouth, the tool is long enough to try. If the jaws cannot open, the hook gets cut.

What a cut-resistant glove does and does not do

A cut-resistant glove is rated for cut, not for bite. ANSI/ISEA 105 sorts gloves from A1 to A9 by the force a blade needs to cut through the material. Level A4 begins at 1,500 grams of cut force. The test draws a blade across a sample. A tooth arrives as a point load, so a glove that resists a sliding blade can still be pierced by a canine or caught and torn by a shaking jaw. The glove's real job is on the support hand. That hand holds the body behind the gill cover while the other works the pliers, and it is the hand most likely to meet a sudden twist. One glove on the support hand and a bare hand on the tool is the usual split, because dexterity matters at the hook and grip matters on the body. Wet the glove before the fish arrives. A dry glove scours the slime coat behind the jaw, and one soaked in bait, fuel or sunscreen carries contamination into the gills. Inspect the palm and fingertips between trips: a nick in the coating collects salt and slime, and a stiff glove loses the feel that makes it useful. A gauntlet reaching the wrist keeps the forearm clear of the flank, where scales and fins do their own damage. A glove also changes behaviour. An angler who trusts it tends to reach further than a bare hand would, which converts protection into exposure. The glove is a backup for the support hand, not a licence to put a hand in a mouth. Treat a gloved hand at the lip line as a bare hand at the lip line.

Controlling the body before the mouth

Control is a position, not a squeeze. The supporting hand goes behind the gill cover, on the body, never on the gill itself. The fish is held horizontal, with the length of the body supported. Suspending a toothy fish by the jaw or by the line puts its weight on a joint that cannot carry it and leaves the mouth free to swing. On a fish above 3 kilograms, one hand is not enough. Use two hands, or keep the fish in the net in the water and work through the mesh. Kneel on a rock ledge so the fish stays low, and keep the body against a wet mat or the deck rather than in the air. A fish turned on its back with its eyes covered often stops thrashing, which buys the seconds the pliers need. A lip gripper keeps the hand away from the teeth, and it concentrates the whole weight of a heavy fish on the lower jaw. On a bluefish or a barracuda that twists, the jaw can tear before the grip releases. Use a gripper to lift a fish that will be kept, not to hang a fish that will be released.

Landing on piers, rocks and boats

On a high pier the net comes first. A toothy fish swinging on a line reaches the rail before it reaches the hand, and 3 kilograms of fish at the end of a leader is a hazard to everyone on the deck. A rubber-mesh or knotless net scuffs eyes, fins and scales less than nylon, and it leaves more of the slime coat intact. On rocks, keep the fish in the water beside the ledge and work downward. Lifting it to chest height removes the option of letting go. In a boat, land the fish over open water, wet the mat, and keep the head pointed away from legs and bare feet. The deck is the wrong place to discover that the pliers are in the bag below. Night changes the sequence. A headlamp aimed at the jaw shows the hook without guessing, and the beam stays out of the fish's eyes. Tools go on a lanyard before dark; with a fish on, there is no free hand for a bag. The rules do not change after sunset. The margin for error does. Pier height changes the mechanics again. Lower a net on a rope, lead the fish over the rim, and lift with the rope rather than the leader. A second person takes the rope while the angler keeps tension off the rod. If the fish is too large for the net, walk it to a ladder or a low section of the pier instead of swinging it up. A fish dropped from height is dead weight on the deck and a hook flying loose.

When to cut instead of removing

Reach for the cutters when the hook has gone past the jaw, when a treble has two points buried, when the fish will not settle, or when the metal sits in a gill arch or the throat. Trim 2 to 3 centimetres above the eye with side cutters rather than a knife. A stub that short gathers no weed, and the hook keeps the angle at which it went in. A cut is a treatment. Metal left in place has a chance of working loose on its own. Plain carbon hooks break down in salt water far sooner than stainless, and that difference is the argument for fishing carbon when a cut is possible. A stainless hook can outlast the fish, so tearing it out is the worse option. Cut, release, and write off the hardware; it costs less than the fish. One attempt, then the cutters. That limit is about time as much as tissue. Sixty seconds of air is the ceiling, and a fish worn down by a long fight reaches the deck already short of oxygen. A toothy fish that is thrashing is also a fish that will bite the hand holding the pliers. Cutting ends the operation sooner for both. Before the next trip, open the pliers and lay them along the jaw of the largest fish you expect to land. If the jaws cannot reach the bend with the hand still behind the hinge, the tool is too short and the fish will be cut rather than unhooked.

Sources

  1. Catch and Release Fishing Best Practices — NOAA Fisheries · T1
  2. Careful Catch and Release — NOAA Fisheries · T1
  3. Catch & Release Tips — Texas Parks and Wildlife Department · T1
  4. Bluefish — NOAA FishWatch · T1
  5. Catch and Release — NOAA Office of National Marine Sanctuaries · T1
  6. Cut Resistant Series Vol. 18: ANSI/ISEA 105 Cut Levels — Watson Gloves · T2