Key facts
| Check | Requirement |
|---|---|
| Approval label | size range, fit and approval number |
| Adult buoyancy floor | 15.5 lb (69 N) for a Type III vest |
| Inflatable buoyancy | 22 lb or 33 lb, depending on model |
| Under 40 ft | one wearable device per person |
| Throwable PFD | required at 16 ft and above |
| Harmonised levels | 50, 70, 100, 150 and 275 |
| Inflatable PFD | must be worn to count |
| Inspection | cartridge, mechanism and indicators before each trip |
The label is the specification
A PFD must be in serviceable condition, of an appropriate size and fit for the intended wearer as marked on the approval label, and legibly marked with its approval number. Those three conditions are separate, and failing any one of them takes the device out of the count even if it still floats. The approval label is not a decoration. It states the size range and fit the device was approved for, and it carries the approval number that identifies the design. A label that has been worn away or painted over removes the only evidence that the device is what it claims to be, which is why the regulation asks for it to remain legible. Use the label to decide who wears which jacket. A device approved for an adult is not made suitable by tightening the straps for a child, and a child's vest does not become an adult device when the child outgrows it. This is a certification question rather than a comfort question: the label defines the wearer, and the wearer should match it. The label also tells you which approval scheme the vest was built under. Older vests carry the Type I to Type V system; newer ones carry the harmonised level marking. Both are legitimate, and both are checked the same way — against the wearer and the boat, not against the price tag.
What the five levels buy you
The harmonised levels describe where a device is intended to be used and how much it is expected to do. Level 50 and Level 70 are foam vests for near-shore and inshore work, with the 70 carrying more buoyancy and a better turning performance. Level 100 and Level 150 are inflatables, the 100 aimed at protected water and the 150 at offshore use where a person may have to float for hours. Level 275 is a high-buoyancy inflatable for heavy clothing, tool belts and conditions where the wearer is carrying weight. None of those numbers is a ranking of quality. A Level 70 foam vest is the correct device for a kayak in a cold estuary where a puncture would defeat an inflatable; a Level 150 inflatable is the correct device for a deckhand working in oilskins offshore, where bulk would make the vest unwearable and an unworn vest protects nobody. Match the level to the water, the clothing and the likelihood of a long immersion, then keep the device in the condition its approval assumes. The old Type system maps roughly onto the same logic. Type I is offshore with the highest turning ability, Type II is near-shore, Type III is a flotation aid for calm water where a conscious wearer can help themselves, Type IV is a throwable cushion or ring, and Type V is a special-purpose device that is only approved for the use printed on its label. A Type III vest that keeps a conscious paddler afloat is not the same device as a Type I that will turn an unconscious person face-up.
Fit: the lift test and the crotch strap
Fit is a performance variable, not a comfort setting. Put the vest on, tighten every strap, and have someone lift the shoulders of the jacket upward. If the vest rides up past the ears, it is too loose, and in the water it will ride up in exactly the same way and leave the airway lower than it should be. The crotch strap is the part owners remove first and need most. Without it, an inflatable that fires at the surface can slide up the torso while the wearer is being pushed by a wave, and a foam vest can be stripped off over the head in surf. A crotch strap turns the vest from a garment into a harness. If the maker supplied one, fit it. Children need a different check. Lift the child by the shoulders of the vest; if the child's chin or ears pass through the neck opening, the vest will not hold the head clear. A child's vest should also have a crotch strap fitted and a grab handle that an adult can use to lift the child clear of the water.
Inherent buoyancy: what foam loses
Foam flotation is reliable because it cannot be forgotten at home and cannot fail to inflate. It also degrades quietly. UV exposure embrittles the outer shell, repeated compression from sitting on the vest flattens the cells, and stored damp foam can grow mildew that rots the fabric from the inside. The serviceable check is physical. Squeeze the flotation through the shell and feel for hard, flattened or lumpy panels. Look for open seams and places where the foam has migrated to one corner. Smell the vest after it has been stored damp; mildew is a fail, not a laundry problem. A foam vest that has lost a third of its thickness in the shoulders will still float a person in a pool and will not do the job in a chop. Foam also has a volume problem. A vest thick enough for offshore winter clothing is hot and bulky, which is exactly why people take it off on a calm afternoon and then cannot put it on in the seconds before a capsize. That trade-off is real, and the answer is to choose the device for the worst ten minutes of the trip rather than the average hour.
Inflatable mechanics: cartridge and bobbin
An inflatable reaches its rated buoyancy — commonly 22 lb or 33 lb depending on the model — by releasing gas into a chamber. The mechanism has three parts that matter: the CO2 cartridge, the firing head, and the water-sensitive element that triggers automatic inflation. A hydrostatic inflator fires on pressure, not on a splash. That distinction is the reason a boat spray or a wave over the bow does not set it off. A bobbin-style inflator dissolves when immersed, and its timing depends on the bobbin being the right type for the expected water temperature and being in date. A cartridge that has been pierced once is empty even though it still weighs something; the indicator, not the weight, is the check. Rearming is a maker-specific procedure. Use the correct cartridge and bobbin, torque the head as instructed, and then confirm the status indicator shows green or armed. Improvised cartridges and cross-brand parts are the most common cause of a vest that looks armed and does nothing. The oral inflation tube is the backup and the maintenance tool. It lets you top up a chamber that has been punctured, and it lets you test the chamber for leaks without firing the cartridge. Inflate by mouth, leave it for an hour, and see whether it holds. A chamber that leaks at the seam will not be saved by a fresh cartridge.
Worn, not stowed
The worn-to-count rule is the one most often missed. A Level 100 or Level 150 inflatable is approved on the condition that it is worn; left on the seat or in a bag it is not doing the job of a wearable, and in some jurisdictions it does not satisfy the carriage requirement at all. The label says so, and the rule exists because an inflatable that is not on the body cannot be put on during a capsize. The same logic applies to foam. Carriage is a legal minimum; wearing is the operational standard. A person who goes over the side in the first thirty seconds of an incident has no time to open a locker, find the right size and work out which strap goes where. The only vest that counts in that window is the one already fitted.
Count versus protection
A recreational vessel needs a wearable device sized for each person on board, and a hull of 16 feet or longer also needs a throwable device that is immediately available. The throwable cannot double as someone's wearable, and a cushion on the console is not a substitute for a vest on a child. For an uninspected boat under 40 feet without paying passengers, the federal floor is a suitably sized approved device for each occupant. Count occupants, not devices in a locker: five jackets for four people means nothing if one is the wrong size or out of service. The number on the label is a floor, not a plan; a device left in its bag still leaves a person without usable flotation when the boat turns.
Cold water changes the arithmetic
A life jacket keeps a person at the surface. It does not keep them warm, and it does not by itself keep the airway clear in rough water. In water below about 15 °C the first response is a gasp and a period of uncontrolled breathing, and a vest that holds the head up is what allows that reflex to pass without a lungful of water. That is the argument for the higher level in cold water rather than the cheaper one. The difference between a 15.5 lb vest and a 22 lb inflatable is not visible on a calm lake; it shows up when the wearer is in oilskins, in a chop, and unable to help. Buy for the water temperature and the clothing, then wear the device rather than carrying it.
Care, storage and retirement
Rinse foam vests in fresh water after salt exposure, dry them in shade rather than direct sun, and store them loose rather than compressed under gear. Do not dry-clean a PFD and do not store it in a sealed bag while damp; both shorten the life of the shell. An inflatable should be stored partly inflated, with the cartridge in place and the head protected, in a dry place away from solvents and battery acid. Check the maker's service interval for the firing head and the cartridge, and treat any vest that has fired in anger as due for a full rearm and inspection before it goes back into service. Retirement is a judgement, not a date. A foam vest with a hardened panel, a torn shell or a mildew smell is finished regardless of its age. An inflatable with a corroded firing head, a sticky lever or a chamber that will not hold air for an hour is finished too. Replacement is cheaper than the alternative.
Action: check the label and the mechanism
Read the approval label. Confirm the size range, the approval number and any worn-to-count statement. Tug the hardware and straps. Look for corrosion, cracks, torn webbing and separated attachment points. Squeeze the flotation. Check for hardened, compressed, waterlogged or mildew-smelling material. Match devices to people. Use the label's size range rather than adjusting an adult vest for a child. Inspect inflatables before every trip. Confirm the cartridge is full, the mechanism is armed and the indicators are working. Inflate the chamber by mouth. Leave it an hour and watch for leaks before you trust the cartridge. Replace, do not repair, a failed device. A jacket that fails a serviceable check is out of the count.
A torn jacket that floats still fails
Counting a torn or corroded jacket because it still floats. Treating a throwable cushion as a wearable for a passenger. Assuming an inflatable counts while it sits on the seat. Ignoring the cartridge date and the bobbin type on an inflatable. Using an adult device for a child because the straps tighten. Reading the approval number as a size guide. Removing the crotch strap because it is uncomfortable on the dock. Section index: environment index.
Sources
- 33 CFR Part 175 Subpart B: Personal Flotation Devices — Electronic Code of Federal Regulations · T1
- 46 CFR 25.25-5: Life preservers and other lifesaving equipment required — US Coast Guard · T1
- 46 CFR 160.276: Inflatable PFDs — Electronic Code of Federal Regulations · T1