Shallow-Water Tides: When the Curve Stops Being a Sine

A tide table lists a high at 10:40 and a low at 16:55. The interval is six hours and fifteen minutes, which looks like half a semidiurnal cycle. What the table does not show is that the water spends the first three hours covering the flat and the next three barely moving, or the reverse.

tides
Cover illustration: Shallow-Water Tides: When the Curve Stops Being a Sine

Key facts

QuestionAnswer
CauseShallow depth and friction distort the wave
Speed relationWave speed falls with the square root of depth
Curve effectRise and fall become unequal in duration
HarmonicsM4 and M6 add shape, not just height
BoreA steep flood front that breaks in a funnel
Table limitHighs and lows only; no shape between
Planning useTime the stage, not just the extremes

Why depth changes the shape

In shallow water the curve between the extremes is not a sine, and the shape decides when a channel opens, when a flat drains and when the current peaks. Reading only the highs and lows is reading the endpoints of a curve whose middle matters more. A tide is a long wave, and its speed depends on depth. In deep water the crest and the trough travel at nearly the same speed and the wave keeps its shape. In shallow water the crest sits in slightly deeper water than the trough, so the crest travels faster and catches up with the trough ahead of it. The result is a wave that steepens on its leading edge. The rise becomes faster than the fall, or the fall faster than the rise, depending on the direction of propagation and the shape of the basin. The distortion is not a small correction; in an estuary with a large range it can change the duration of the rise by an hour or more. Friction adds to the effect. It slows the wave and removes energy, and it acts more strongly on the fast-moving crest than on the slow trough. The combination of steepening and damping produces the asymmetric curves that tide tables summarise as a pair of times and heights. The ratio that matters is tidal amplitude against mean depth. A half-metre range over twenty metres of water leaves the wave almost undistorted, because the crest and the trough travel in nearly the same depth. A three-metre range over five metres of depth is a different problem: the crest crosses the same bottom at eight metres and runs about a quarter faster than the trough. That speed gap, applied across a six-hour flood, is what bends the curve. Depth comes from the chart, amplitude from the nearest gauge, and the quotient between them tells you whether to expect a sine.

Overtides carry the shape

The distortion is represented mathematically by shallow-water overtides. M4 has half the period of M2 and adds a second crest and trough within each cycle. M6 has one third of the period and sharpens the curve further. The phase of the overtide relative to M2 decides the result. In one phase the rise is compressed and the fall stretched; in the opposite phase the reverse occurs. M4 in quadrature with M2 produces a curve that is steep on both sides and flat at the top, which is one route to a double high water. The overtides grow with the amplitude of the parent tide, so the distortion is stronger at spring than at neap. A station that looks nearly sinusoidal at neap can be strongly asymmetric at spring, and the change is a property of the range rather than of the station. Once an estuary has been shaped by a distorted tide, the shape feeds back into the tide. A flood that is concentrated in a deep channel scours that channel, while a slow ebb that spreads across flats deposits sediment there. The result is a self-reinforcing geometry: the channel stays deep, the flats stay shallow, and the asymmetry persists. That is why the curves at a long-established station are stable from year to year, and why dredging or reclamation can shift them.

Three common shapes

The first shape is a fast rise and a slow fall. The flood arrives quickly, the high water is brief, and the ebb drains gradually. This is common in estuaries where the flood is concentrated in a deep channel and the ebb spreads across wide flats. The second is a slow rise and a fast fall. The flood creeps up over a shallow gradient, the high water stands, and the ebb accelerates as the flats drain. This shape is common where the flood has to fill a large storage area before the level rises appreciably. The third is a bore. In a funnel-shaped estuary with a large range, the flood front steepens until it breaks into a travelling wave. The Severn Estuary in England, the Qiantang in China and the Pororoca on the Amazon all produce bores, and the height and timing depend on the range, the river flow and the shape of the channel. A bore is a special case, but the mechanism is the same steepening that produces the asymmetric curve. The difference is that the front has become steep enough to break.

Where the shape is felt

The distortion is felt first in the current. A fast-rise curve produces a short, strong flood and a long, weak ebb, which is flood dominance. A fast-fall curve produces the reverse. The current peaks are not at the height extremes, and a plan built on the height curve will be early or late. It is felt second in the depth over structure. A flat that covers on the steep part of the rise goes from dry to knee-deep in less time than the same flat on a symmetrical curve. A boat that anchors on the edge of such a flat can be floating in twenty minutes and aground an hour later, without any change in the range. It is felt third in the behaviour of lures and baits. A short, strong flood requires heavier terminal tackle and a more direct presentation; a long, weak ebb allows lighter tackle and slower retrieves. The same mark can require two different setups on the two phases, and the difference is the shape of the curve rather than the height of the tide.

What the table cannot tell you

A tide table gives the time and height of high and low water. It does not give the time at which the water reaches an intermediate level, and that is the number that matters for access. A flat that covers at 0.8 m may be dry at 09:00 and wet at 10:30, even though low water was at 06:00 and high water is at 12:00. The intermediate level is reached on the steep part of the curve, and the timing depends on the shape, not on the extremes. Interpolating straight between the extremes is the usual shortcut, and on a distorted curve it lands in the wrong half hour. Take a low of 0.3 m at 06:00 and a high of 3.1 m at 12:00, with a flat that covers at 1.2 m. A straight line puts the covering at 07:56. If the first three hours of the flood carry 80% of the rise, that 0.9 m is done in 1.2 hours and the flat covers near 07:10. The three quarters of an hour between the two answers is the shape, not the table's arithmetic. The same applies to a channel that needs a metre of water over a sill. The sill may be passable for only an hour, and that hour can sit anywhere between low and high depending on the curve. The table gives the endpoints; the curve gives the window.

The bore as a timing signal

Where a bore runs, it is the most precise timing signal on the estuary. The front arrives as a visible line of breaking water, often with a roar, and it marks the start of the flood at that point. The time between the bore's arrival and the subsequent high water is short, and the water behind the front rises quickly. A bore also carries hazards. The front can be a metre or more high, it moves faster than a person can run on wet mud, and it picks up debris. Boats and boards have been caught by bores in the Severn and the Qiantang, and the currents behind the front are strong. River flow decides whether a bore forms and how big it is. A high discharge deepens the channel and speeds the front, which can make the bore stronger; too much discharge can flatten it by raising the downstream level. The best bores usually occur on a large spring tide with a moderate river, which is why they are not equally impressive on every tide. The bore's timing is also a check on the tide table. A bore that arrives an hour before the predicted low-water turn at the mouth is telling you that the flood is already running upstream while the outer gauge still shows a falling level. That is a phase difference between two stations in the same estuary, and it is worth recording. For fishing, the bore marks the arrival of clear, well-oxygenated water and the start of the flood. The period just behind the front can be productive, but the window is short and the position must be safe before the water arrives.

Using the shape

Plot the predicted curve if the station publishes hourly heights, or use a tide app that shows the curve rather than only the extremes. Mark the height at which the route closes, the flat covers or the sill clears, and read the time from the curve. Where the plan depends on a draining tide, the shape tells you whether the drain will be gradual or abrupt. A fast-fall curve concentrates the fishing into a short period and makes the exit time critical. A slow-fall curve gives a longer window but a weaker current. Where the plan depends on a rising tide, the shape tells you when the water will arrive. A fast-rise curve can cover a flat in less time than it takes to walk back, and the margin has to reflect the speed of the rise rather than the range alone. Diurnal inequality is the other term to check. Where the two high waters of a day differ in height, the usable stage arrives twice with different windows, and a plan built on the morning high fails on the evening one. The gap between the two highs is often wider than the clearance a sill needs, so a mark that is workable at 10:00 sits dry through the lower high later the same day. Read both highs before deciding that the mark works on the day.

The practical check

The final check is to watch a fixed rock or post through one rise. Note the time when the water reaches each ten-centimetre mark. If the intervals are unequal, the curve is distorted and the table's endpoints are not enough. That observation takes an hour and gives a local calibration that no published table contains. It is the difference between planning on a shape and planning on two numbers.

Sources

  1. Tidal Asymmetry — Coastal Wiki · T2
  2. Tidal Bore — Coastal Wiki · T2
  3. Understanding Tides — NOAA Center for Operational Oceanographic Products and Services · T1
  4. Tides — NOAA JetStream · T1