Seals and Gulls: Landing Etiquette That Avoids a Fight

Wildlife does not attack a bait pile for the same reason it attacks an angler. It comes for the food, learns that boats and buckets are reliable sources, and loses its fear of people. The result looks like aggression; the cause is a handout, a hooked fish, or a nest too close to the path.

safety and hazards
Cover illustration: Seals and Gulls: Landing Etiquette That Avoids a Fight

Key facts

SituationSafe moveMinimum space
Seal near the boatPull in the line, stop casting, move away50 feet; 150 feet for a mother with a pup
Turtle in the water or on the sandStop fishing, let it pass10 feet
Dolphin or small whaleStop the boat, drift away50 yards
Large whaleStop, keep clear of the track100 yards
Gull or heron after baitCover the bait, move the rodDo not feed or cast at it
Dog on the beachLeash and move awayLeash required in public

Why wildlife targets anglers

A seal that has learned to take fish from a line is not a random encounter. It has found a place where food arrives on a hook and will return to that boat, ramp or cleaning table. A gull diving on a bait bucket has learned the same lesson, and a heron on the bank has learned that a hooked fish spends time near the surface. That is why the first rule is not defence: it is not creating the habit. Feeding, discarding scraps and leaving bait uncovered teach animals that people are a food source, and the lesson spreads. It is also against federal law to feed or attempt to feed marine mammals, and Hawaii protects sea turtles as well. The legal frame is the Marine Mammal Protection Act, which prohibits the take and harassment of marine mammals. Harassment is not limited to touching an animal. It includes pursuit, torment and annoyance that has the potential to injure a marine mammal or disturb its behaviour, and a boat that drives at a seal to move it off a mark can meet that definition without any contact at all. The practical translation is simple: the animal's behaviour, not the angler's intent, is the test.

A thumb at arm's length measures 50 feet

NOAA's guidance includes a distance check that works without a rangefinder. Hold your thumb at arm's length and line it up with the animal. You are far enough away when your thumb covers the entire seal; at that arm's length the distance is about 50 feet. The rule is a minimum, not a target. A seal can move faster than a person can back away, and a seal that has been fed may not stop at 50 feet. The gesture gives a repeatable check before you are close enough to guess. A mother with a pup is the exception. Give them at least 150 feet. A mother seal can be very protective, and a pup on a beach is not a photo opportunity. Stay behind signs and barriers. Haul-out sites deserve the same treatment as a pup. Seals come ashore to rest, moult and warm up, and a group on a rock is not a group in distress. Landing a boat into the middle of a haul-out scatters animals into the water, separates mothers from pups and costs the group the rest it came ashore for. Anchor short of the site and fish the edge.

Turtles, dolphins and whales

Sea turtles need at least 10 feet of space on land and in the water in Hawaii. A turtle sleeping on the sand is not stranded, and one at the surface is not asking to be touched. Use the zoom, and let it leave on its own. Dolphins and small whales need at least 50 yards; large whales need at least 100 yards, and federal law prohibits approaching a large whale within that distance by boat, kayak, drone or swimming. If one appears, stop the propeller and let it move away. Do not chase it for a photograph or turn across its path. A dolphin riding a bow wave is not an invitation. The animal is using the pressure wave, and a turn or a sudden change in speed can put it under the hull. Hold course and speed, or slow down and let it go. A whale that surfaces close to the boat is a reason to stop, not to accelerate away; a propeller strike is the most serious injury an angler can cause in a single moment.

When a seal takes your bait or fish

This is the case the FAST guidelines were written for. Fishing Around Seals and Turtles asks anglers to notify the Marine Animal Response Hotline at 1-888-256-9840 if a seal is seen taking bait or fish. The call is how the response network learns that an animal is interacting with gear. Pull in the line when a seal is in the area. Do not leave gear unattended, and check bait often. A seal that takes a baited hook can become hooked or entangled, and a hooked seal is a danger to the animal and to anyone who tries to free it. Do not feed the seal to distract it, and do not throw scraps to keep it away; both reward the approach. A swat, a gaff or a cast at the animal turns a food interaction into an injury risk. A seal that is already hooked should not be reeled to the boat. The animal is large, powerful and will bite when handled, and a hook in a flipper or a lip is not a problem an angler can solve on deck. Call the hotline, note the position and the animal's condition, and cut the line as close as is safe. A trailing length of line is a better outcome than a fight at the gunwale.

Gulls and herons

Gulls work in groups and learn quickly. One dive on an uncovered bait bucket is enough to bring the flock back. Cover the bait, keep the catch in a closed bin, and do not leave a fish on deck while re-rigging. A gull that takes a whole fish usually takes the hook too. A hooked gull is a handling problem with a sharp end at both ends. Do not reel it through the air toward the boat. Bring it in slowly, cover the bird with a towel or a jacket to calm it, control the wings against the body, and cut the line at the hook rather than pulling it out. A bite from a gull is a wound that needs cleaning and a tetanus check, and a bird that is struggling can break a wing against the gunwale. Herons are ambush feeders. They stand on a bank or piling, wait for a hooked fish, and stab. The bill is fast and accurate, and a hand that tries to shoo it away can be injured. Move the fish or the boat, and do not cast at the bird. The landing etiquette is the same: no feeding, no scraps, no unattended bait. A bird that is not rewarded moves on; one that is fed becomes a hazard at the cleaning table.

Landing and cleaning etiquette

Clean fish away from turtles and seals, and never discard fish scraps in the water or a harbour. The scraps attract seals and gulls, and a harbour that feeds wildlife creates bold animals at every slip. Take frames and skin home, or put them in a closed bin wildlife cannot open. Do not discard fish waste on the beach. A carcass draws dogs, gulls and flies, and it brings people and animals into conflict at the same spot. A cleaning station bin is better than a rock at the waterline, but only if it is closed and the scraps go out with the boat. Keep gear attended. A rod left in a holder with bait in the water is a hook waiting for a turtle or a seal. Pull it in when you walk away, even for a few minutes; most entanglements start with an unattended line. The cleaning table is the place where a small habit becomes a local problem. A station that hoses scraps into the harbour trains every gull in the marina, and the birds then work the slips where boats are tied. Bag the frames, wipe the table, and use the bin. The same discipline applies at a remote ramp with no bin: the waste goes home.

Dogs on the beach

Hawaii law requires dogs to be leashed in public spaces except designated dog parks. A leashed dog cannot chase a seal, turtle or gull into the water. Keep the leash short near wildlife, and do not let a dog approach a pup. A dog is also a bite risk to the angler. A dog that lunges at a hooked fish or a bird on the line can drive a hook into a hand or a face. Tie the dog short and away from the gear, and do not use it to move an animal off the beach.

What not to do

Do not hook, gaff, swat or kick an animal that takes your bait. Do not chase a seal or turtle for a photograph, corner one against a rock or a crowd, or put a drone over a whale. Do not feed any of them to keep them around. If an animal is hooked or entangled, call the hotline. For a hooked turtle, NOAA advises calling for guidance, reeling it in carefully, holding it by the shell, and cutting the line close to the hook while leaving the hook in place.

Action list

Keep bait covered and the catch in a closed bin. Pull in the line when a seal, turtle or bird is near. Use the thumb rule: 50 feet from a seal, 150 feet from a mother and pup. Give turtles 10 feet, dolphins and small whales 50 yards, large whales 100 yards. Never feed marine mammals or turtles, and never throw scraps to distract them. Call 1-888-256-9840 if a seal takes bait or fish, or if an animal is hooked. Take fish waste home and keep the dog leashed.

Mistakes that invite wildlife

Feeding a seal to keep it away from the boat. Leaving a baited rod unattended. Casting at a gull that is diving on the bait. Cleaning fish at the waterline and throwing frames in. Reeling a hooked bird through the air instead of cutting the line. Letting a dog run at a seal or a turtle. Chasing a dolphin or whale for a better view. Section index: environment index.

Sources

  1. 10 Things You Can Do to Share the Shore and Sea With Pacific Islands Wildlife — NOAA Fisheries · T1
  2. Marine Protected Species — Hawaii DLNR Division of Aquatic Resources · T1
  3. Marine Mammal Protection Act — NOAA Fisheries · T1