Landing Net: Buy for the Load at Full Extension

A landing net is the only piece of tackle that is loaded with a live animal, a moving frame and a lever arm all at once. The failure mode is not subtle: a handle that extends for reach loses lifting capacity in proportion, a hoop that is too small folds the fish, and a mesh that is too abrasive removes the slime coat that protects it after release.

hooks and accessories
Cover illustration: Landing Net: Buy for the Load at Full Extension

Key facts

Key factDetail
EGO S2 Slider large rubber netHoop 19 by 21 in, bag depth 24 in, handle 29 to 60 in
EGO load rating30 lb retracted, 24 lb partly extended, 20 lb fully extended
EGO net weight3.35 lb
Frabill Heavy Duty Conservation NetHoop 26 by 30 in, bag depth 38 in, handle 48 to 96 in
Frabill mesh1 in knotless micromesh, linear bottom, mesh guard
Load drop from retracted to extendedAbout one third of the rating
Frabill handleCamlock telescoping, 48 to 96 in
NOAA guidanceWet, soft knotless mesh or rubber net; keep the fish in the water
Mass.gov guidanceRubber net preserves the mucus membrane and allows handling in the water

The load is rated at the handle

The specifications that matter are printed on the net or published by the maker, and they are easy to compare once you know which number applies to your fishing. EGO publishes three load figures for one net: 30 lb with the handle retracted, 24 lb partly extended and 20 lb fully extended. The mesh is the same in all three cases. What changes is the distance between the load and the hand, and that distance is a lever. The further the hoop is from the grip, the more bending moment the frame and the lock have to carry for the same fish. That is why a net rated for 30 lb is not a net that will lift a 30 lb fish at full reach. The rating describes the strongest configuration, and the angler who extends the handle to reach a fish under a dock is working with two-thirds of that number. The practical rule is to buy for the extended rating, not the headline figure, and to lift vertically whenever the fish is heavy. Vertical lift is not a stylistic preference. EGO's own instructions say to lift heavier loads more vertically, because a vertical pull puts the frame in compression and the handle in line with the load. A horizontal scoop at full extension puts the same weight across the lever and multiplies the stress at the lock. The weight of the net itself matters in the same direction. The EGO large deep rubber net weighs 3.35 lb. That is light for a rubber net of that size, but it is still mass at the end of an arm, and it is the number that decides whether a one-handed scoop is possible from a kayak or a low boat.

Hoop size decides whether the fish fits

A hoop is not a target; it is the opening the fish has to pass through without folding. The EGO large hoop is 19 by 21 in, and the Frabill heavy-duty hoop is 26 by 30 in. The Frabill opening is roughly twice the area, which is the difference between netting a fish head-first in one motion and chasing it around the rim. The fish's girth, not its length, sets the minimum hoop. A long, slender fish can be landed in a hoop narrower than its length because it enters nose-first and lies along the bag. A deep-bodied fish of the same length has to pass its widest section through the rim, and a hoop narrower than that section forces the fish to bend or turns the landing into a push. Measure the widest part of the fish you expect, add margin for the fish to be off-centre, and choose the hoop from that number. Bigger is not automatically better. A 26 by 30 in hoop is harder to move through the water, catches wind on the cast and takes more space on a kayak deck. On a small boat, a large hoop that cannot be swung in one motion lands fewer fish than a smaller hoop that can. The right size is the largest hoop that can be handled cleanly in the space where it will be used.

Bag depth changes how the fish behaves

The Frabill bag is 38 in deep; the EGO deep rubber bag is 24 in, both with a flat bottom. Depth does two things. It gives a thrashing fish room to drop away from the rim instead of hitting the frame, and it lets the bag stay in the water while the fish recovers. A shallow bag holds the fish against the hoop, which is exactly where a hook or a treble is still swinging. A flat, linear bottom supports the fish along its length rather than at one point. Frabill lists a linear bottom as a design feature, and the reason is mechanical: a fish supported along its belly is less likely to bend or to have its organs loaded by a narrow sling. A deep V bag concentrates the load in the middle, which is fine for small fish and poor for heavy ones. Deep bags have a cost in water resistance. A 38 in bag scooping forward moves a lot of water, and the drag is felt at the handle. That is one reason a big conservation net is a two-handed tool. Match the bag depth to the fish: deep for fish that thrash and for catch-and-release, shallower for small fish where speed matters more than calm.

Mesh: rubber, knotless nylon and the slime coat

Mass.gov states the case plainly: a rubber net preserves the fish's mucus membrane, which protects it from disease and infection, and it allows the fish to be handled in the water. NOAA's catch-and-release guidance adds that a wet, soft knotless mesh or a rubber landing net causes less damage to a fish's eyes, fins, scales and protective mucus coating. Both agencies point the same way, and neither is selling a net. Rubber mesh has three practical advantages. It does not absorb slime, it does not snag treble hooks, and it does not abrade a fish that rolls against it. The cost is weight and water drag: a rubber bag is heavier than nylon and sheds water more slowly. That is why the EGO rubber net is built around a 3.35 lb frame and a load-rated handle rather than a light trout frame. Knotless nylon is the lighter compromise. Frabill's 1 in micromesh is knotless, which removes the small hard knots that catch fins and eyes, and the fine mesh reduces the chance of a fish's head passing through. It drains faster than rubber and weighs less. It will still snag a treble, and a hooked fish rolling in nylon can wrap the hook into the mesh, which is a slower release than rubber. Knotted mesh is the wrong choice for release fishing. The knots are abrasive, the openings are large enough to catch fins, and a fish can be damaged simply by being lifted. It remains common on cheap nets and on bait nets where the catch is not released.

Handle length is a reach decision with a load penalty

The Frabill handle extends from 48 to 96 in; the EGO from 29 to 60 in. The Frabill is a bank, pier and big-boat net, and the EGO is a boat and kayak net. The difference is not just reach. A longer handle is a longer lever, and the same fish applies more torque at the grip. Telescoping mechanisms matter as much as length. Frabill uses a camlock with an automatic locking yoke; EGO uses a push-button slider with preset positions. A camlock that slips under load lets the handle collapse at the worst moment, and a push-button that will not seat leaves the net short. Check the lock with the net extended and a weight in the bag before trusting it over water. Reach has a second limit that is not mechanical. A net at full extension is hard to aim, and a miss with a long handle is slower to recover than a miss with a short one. On a crowded pier or a rocky shore, the angler who can place a short net accurately lands more fish than the one who reaches further and misses.

Frame, flotation and salt

Frames are aluminium, composite or a mix. Aluminium is stiff and light but corrodes at scratches, especially in salt water; composite frames resist corrosion and float, but they are bulkier. Frabill describes its heavy-duty net as corrosion-proof composite construction. That is a manufacturer's description of the material, not a lifetime guarantee, and the joints and locks still need fresh water after every saltwater trip. Flotation is a feature worth paying for on a boat. A net that sinks is a net that is gone, and a net that floats is one that can be retrieved after a fumble. The trade is bulk: foam in the frame or handle adds volume and can make the net harder to stow. A net that will live on a boat should be rinsed in fresh water, opened and dried before storage. Salt crystallises in the lock and in the mesh, and a folded wet bag grows mildew that damages the coating. The frame should be checked for cracks at the yoke, because that is where the bending load concentrates.

Matching the net to the fishery

A bass boat needs a wide hoop, a deep bag and a handle long enough to reach over the gunwale without leaning. A 26 by 30 in hoop with a 38 in bag is a reasonable match for fish that are netted at the boat and released. A kayak needs the opposite: a short handle, a hoop that can be swung with one hand, and a bag that does not act like a sea anchor. The EGO 19 by 21 in net at 29 to 60 in fits that brief better than a big conservation net. Shore and pier fishing sit in between. The fish is often below the angler, so reach matters, but the net has to be lifted vertically over a rail. A long handle helps with the reach and hurts with the lift, which is why the load rating at extension is the number to check before buying. Surf fishing adds sand and wave action. A net that is set down in the wash takes grit into the lock, and a rubber bag full of sand is heavy. Rinse the lock after every session and shake the bag out before folding it.

When a net is the wrong tool

NOAA's fish survival guidelines note that landing nets should be avoided where possible for some fish, because handling and time out of water are the risks that matter most. A net is a handling tool, and every use is a trade between control and contact. A fish that is larger than the hoop should not be forced into it. A net that is too small folds the fish, loads the frame beyond its rating and turns a controlled release into a wrestling match. For fish that cannot be netted safely, the alternatives are a larger hoop, a lip gaff where the fishery allows it, or releasing the fish beside the boat without removing it from the water. Some fish should not be netted at all. Billfish, large sharks and tuna are handled with a leader or a release tool, and netting them is both ineffective and dangerous. Fish with spines, such as catfish and scorpionfish, can tangle in any mesh and should be handled with a sling or a cradle rather than a bag. Protected species should be released by cutting the line, not by lifting them into a net. A net is also the wrong tool when the regulations do not allow landing. Some fisheries require release without removing the fish from the water, and a net that lifts the fish is a violation regardless of how gently it is used.

The buying checklist

Start with the fish: the widest section sets the hoop, the expected weight sets the load rating at the extension you will actually use, and the release plan sets the mesh. Then check the handle lock with the net extended, the bag depth against the way the fish behaves, and the frame material against the water. Weight matters last, but it matters more on a kayak than on a pier. The net that gets used is the one that is ready. A big conservation net left in the truck because it is awkward is worth less than a compact rubber net that lives beside the seat. Buy for the fishing you do most, check the extended load rating rather than the headline number, and rinse the salt out before it dries.

Sources

  1. Heavy Duty Conservation Net — Frabill · T1
  2. Kryptek S2 Slider-Large Deep Rubber Net — EGO Fishing · T1
  3. Responsible angler techniques for saltwater fishing — Massachusetts Division of Marine Fisheries · T1
  4. Catch and Release Fishing Best Practices — NOAA Fisheries · T1
  5. Fish Survival Guidelines — NOAA Fisheries · T1