Key facts
| Item | Figure |
|---|---|
| Civil ceiling, per violation | $100,000 |
| Each day of a continuing violation | Separate offence |
| Criminal fine, basic offence | $100,000 or 6 months |
| Aggravated criminal ceiling | $200,000 or 10 years |
| NOAA settlement, undersized cobia | $275 |
| NOAA settlement, charter without Gulf permit | $3,000 |
| NOAA settlement, ten red snapper after closure | $1,000 |
| DFO fine, undersized lobster | $8,500 |
| DFO fine, fishing without a licence | $5,000 |
| DFO sentence, obstruction plus probation | $500 and 12 months |
Two tracks from one prohibition
The published records show how the stack is applied in practice: most cases settle far below the ceiling, and the amount is built from the facts rather than read off a schedule. The Magnuson-Stevens Act does not write a price list. It prohibits a set of acts, then attaches two separate enforcement tracks to them. Section 1858 is the civil track: an administrative assessment by the Secretary of Commerce after notice and a hearing. Section 1859 is the criminal track: a prosecution in federal court for the subsets of conduct that Congress treated as offences. The split matters because the same trip can produce both. A vessel fishing in a closed area, retaining fish over a limit and failing to keep a log can be assessed civilly for each violation and, where the conduct falls inside section 1859, prosecuted criminally as well. The civil assessment does not require a criminal conviction, and a criminal acquittal does not erase the civil case. The practical difference is who decides. A civil case is decided by the agency, with review in a district court if the respondent files within 30 days of the order. A criminal case is decided by a court under the ordinary rules of evidence and proof beyond a reasonable doubt. That is why the civil side carries the volume and the criminal side carries the headlines.
The civil ceiling, and why the bill is usually smaller
Section 1858 caps the civil penalty at $100,000 for each violation. The cap is a ceiling, not a starting point. The same subsection lists what the Secretary must weigh: the nature, circumstances, extent and gravity of the prohibited acts, the violator's degree of culpability, any history of prior offences, and other matters that justice requires. Ability to pay may also be considered, but only if the violator supplies the information at least 30 days before the administrative hearing. Two features turn a single incident into several violations. The first is the per-violation count: a bag overage can be counted by fish, a closed-area tow by set, a reporting failure by trip. The second is the daily rule. A continuing violation is a new offence on each day it continues, so a gear violation that stays in the water for a week is not one violation with a larger number attached; it is seven. The section also reaches the boat. A fishing vessel used in a prohibited act, including its gear, furniture, appurtenances, stores and cargo, is liable in rem for the civil penalty, and the penalty becomes a maritime lien on the vessel. That is how an enforcement case can survive a change of ownership: the lien travels with the hull, not with the captain's employment contract. The agency does not have to collect the maximum. Section 1858 lets the Secretary compromise, modify or remit a penalty with or without conditions. In practice most published outcomes are summary settlements, which are agreed amounts rather than adjudicated penalties. A settlement of a few hundred dollars is therefore evidence of how the agency prices a fact pattern, not evidence of the statutory maximum for that fact pattern.
The criminal track and the aggravated ceiling
Section 1859 is narrower. It makes a criminal offence of the acts listed in section 1857(1)(D), (E), (F), (H), (I) and (L), and of the conduct described in section 1857(2). Those provisions cover the core prohibitions: fishing in a closed area, retaining prohibited species, exceeding a limit, using prohibited gear, interfering with an observer or officer, and the related conduct listed there. The ordinary punishment is a fine of up to $100,000, imprisonment for up to six months, or both. The aggravated form raises the ceiling to $200,000 and the prison term to 10 years when the offender uses a dangerous weapon, causes bodily injury to an observer or an authorised officer, or places either of them in fear of imminent bodily injury. A separate category of offence carries a fine of up to $200,000 without the same prison ladder. The gap between the two sections is the point. The civil side is calibrated to the value of the fishery and the cost of the violation. The criminal side is calibrated to conduct that Congress wanted prosecuted, and the aggravated tier is aimed at violence and intimidation rather than at the size of the catch. An angler who never touches a commercial permit can still meet the criminal section, because the underlying prohibitions apply to recreational fishing in federal waters.
The docket: what a checked trip costs
The published enforcement summaries are more useful than the ceiling because they show the arithmetic. In the week reported on 20 August 2018, NOAA's Office of Law Enforcement listed outcomes from four divisions. The amounts varied by two orders of magnitude, and the reason was the fact pattern rather than the species. In the Southeast, an officer issued a $275 summary settlement offer to a recreational angler for one undersized cobia. On the same patrol series, the captain of a charter vessel harvesting reef fish in federal waters without a federal Gulf of Mexico charter permit received a $3,000 offer. A shrimp boat with gear flaps sewn beyond the permitted distance received $200, and a boat with a TED violation received $100. The red snapper case shows how the count works. Anglers aboard a federal charter vessel kept ten red snapper after the season closed. The captain accepted responsibility and gave a written statement, and the officer issued a $1,000 summary settlement offer. That is $100 per fish, not a $1,000 base fine; the number moves with the count, and the admission affects the outcome without erasing it. Alaska produced a wider spread in the same week. A guide who retained a halibut and failed to log a client's licence number received a $1,000 settlement. A vessel operator with a halibut overage received $4,325. Two commercial halibut boats that exceeded quota were settled at $294 and $858. The largest number in the list belongs to the operator whose overage was measured in pounds of fish, and the smallest to the boat whose breach was a quota technicality. The lesson from the table is that the violation with the clearest evidence is not always the most expensive. A missing permit carries a fixed commercial consequence, a closed-season catch is priced per fish, and a quota overage is priced by weight. An angler planning a trip can use the pattern: the licence, the season and the bag are the three lines that generate most of the small cases, and each one is cheap to get right.
Canada: convictions published as a price list
Fisheries and Oceans Canada publishes convictions by region, and the Gulf region list for 2026 reads like a price list because each row names the section, the place of judgment, the species and the penalty. The page is a record of findings, not of allegations, so the amounts sit closer to final outcomes than a summary settlement does. The size cases set the floor. An undersized lobster conviction drew $8,500 in April, and another drew $4,000, with smaller entries at $1,400 and $750. Possession of female lobster with eggs attached drew $2,000 in one case and $1,500 in another. Fishing without a licence drew $5,000 in two separate cases, and a related possession charge added $1,500 in each. The procedural cases are cheaper but carry conditions that outlast the fine. Obstructing or hindering a fishery officer drew $500 with 12 months of probation in one case, $700 in another, and $500 with probation in a third that also involved undersized oysters. Failing to submit an electronic logbook drew $1,500, an incomplete logbook drew $1,500, and offloading without a dockside observer drew $1,000. Inaccurate hail weights on a halibut landing drew $1,050. Two features of the Canadian list are worth carrying to any jurisdiction. The first is that the regulator publishes the section number, so the same conduct can be traced to the rule that prohibits it. The second is that the sentence can include probation, which is a continuing obligation rather than a one-time payment. A fine is over when it is paid; a probation order is not.
Gear, catch and the permit
Confiscation is the part of the penalty that anglers underestimate, because it does not appear in the fine column. Under the U.S. framework, the vessel and its gear can be proceeded against in rem, which means the case can be brought against the property even when the person is not before the court. A forfeiture can therefore cost more than the assessment that triggered it. The permit sanction is the commercial equivalent. Section 1858 allows the Secretary to revoke, suspend or deny a permit, or to attach additional conditions, when a vessel or permit holder has been involved in a prohibited act, has an overdue civil penalty or criminal fine, or has failed to pay for observer services. The sanction survives a sale: the owner must disclose a pending or effective sanction to a buyer in writing, and the transfer does not extinguish it. A suspended permit is reinstated when the penalty and interest are paid. For a recreational angler the practical form of this is the licence and the record. A licence that is not on the person, a catch record that was not written at the moment of retention, and a stamp that was not bought are all independent failures, and each can be cited even when the fish itself was legal. That is why the enforcement cases cluster around paperwork: the paperwork is what an officer can see at the ramp, and the fish in the cooler is what the paperwork is supposed to explain.
Reading a penalty schedule backwards
A penalty schedule is best read backwards, from the outcome to the decision. The most expensive outcomes in the published lists are not the ones with the most dramatic facts; they are the ones with the most countable violations, the least documentation and the least cooperation. The cheapest are the ones where a single clear rule was broken and the facts were accepted. That produces a short list for any trip. Buy the licence and the stamps before the season starts, and carry them on the water. Write the catch record when the fish is kept, not at the ramp. Read the closure and the size floor before the first cast, because both are strict and neither has a discretion clause. Keep the logbook current if the trip is commercial, because the logbook cases in the Canadian list cost as much as some of the fish cases. None of that is a guarantee. Enforcement discretion, the number of violations charged, the presence of a prior record and the quality of the documentation all move the number. But the structure of the penalty is predictable: a civil ceiling of $100,000, a criminal ceiling that reaches $200,000 and 10 years for aggravated conduct, a vessel that can be named, and a permit that can be suspended. The published cases show where the real cases land, and they land far below the ceiling.
Related reading
How to read a fishery regulation — the six fields an officer checks before a penalty is calculated. Licences for visitors — the first document that turns a stop at the ramp into a citation. Fish size limits: total length and fork length — the measurement that decides an undersized-fish case. Australia: Western Australia fishing rules — a state system where the licence and the species rules sit in different documents.
Regulations effective from 1990-11-28. Check the current local notice before you fish.
Sources
- 16 U.S. Code § 1858 — Civil penalties and permit sanctions — Cornell Law School, Legal Information Institute · T1
- 16 U.S. Code § 1859 — Criminal offenses — Cornell Law School, Legal Information Institute · T1
- Weekly Highlights — August 20, 2018 — NOAA Fisheries · T1
- Gulf region convictions under the Fisheries Act — Fisheries and Oceans Canada · T1
Official sources
- 16 U.S. Code § 1858 — Civil penalties and permit sanctions — Cornell Law School, Legal Information Institute · in force 1990-11-28 · accessed 2026-11-14
- 16 U.S. Code § 1859 — Criminal offenses — Cornell Law School, Legal Information Institute · in force 1990-11-28 · accessed 2026-11-14
- Weekly Highlights — August 20, 2018 — NOAA Fisheries · in force 2018-08-20 · accessed 2026-11-14
- Gulf region convictions under the Fisheries Act — Fisheries and Oceans Canada · accessed 2026-11-14