Protected bycatch: cut for turtles, never cut for birds

The standard advice, cut the line, is right for a turtle and wrong for a bird. A trailing line drowns a seabird. That single difference is the reason protected-species handling has to be learned per animal, not as one rule.

Targetssea turtles, seabirds, marine mammals
Watersaltwater
RegionsGlobal
Methodsbottom, trolling, surf
Quick answer

Cut for turtles and marine mammals, reel in for seabirds, and never remove a hook you cannot see.

Why the official guides contradict each other

NOAA's national advice for sea turtles is to leave the hook in place and leave at least 2 ft of line, so that trained responders can dehook the animal. NOAA's Pacific Islands guidance, written for the same species in a different fishery, says to cut the line as close to the hook as possible and release the animal with no line attached. Both are official, and they are not describing the same situation.

The 2 ft instruction assumes a response network that will recover the animal. It is a marker, a handle and a trace of what happened. The close-cut instruction assumes the animal will not be seen again and that a trailing line is the greater danger. Which one applies depends on whether anyone is coming to help.

Seabirds are the opposite case. NOAA's seabird guidance is blunt: do not cut or break the line. An injured or tangled bird that is cut loose can drown, starve or be taken by a predator, and the line is what lets you bring it aboard and remove the hook. The same action that helps a turtle kills a bird.

That is the whole article in one paragraph. Identify the animal first, then choose the protocol. Reaching for the cutters before you know what is on the line is how well-intentioned releases go wrong.

The cost of getting it backwards is asymmetric. A turtle released with a long tag of line is usually recoverable by a response team. A bird released with a long tag of line is usually not recoverable by anyone, and the same length of line that is a minor problem for a turtle is a death sentence for a seabird.

The sequence with a hooked sea turtle

Slow the boat or stop it, and bring the turtle alongside without lifting it by the shell or dragging it up a beach. A turtle is strong and its flippers are not handles. Hold it by the shell only if you must control it, and keep its head away from your hands.

Look at the hook before you touch anything. If the hook is visible in the mouth or jaw, back it out with a dehooker. If it is swallowed or deeply lodged, do not attempt removal. Cut the line as close to the hook as you can reach, or leave at least 2 ft if a response team is on the way and has asked you to.

If the turtle is tangled, cut in a sequence. Cut the line at the mouth first, then anything around the flippers and neck, then the remaining gear. Cutting the flipper wraps first leaves the turtle anchored by the mouth, which is the most dangerous wrap of all.

Release it head-first into the water without dropping it from a height. If it is exhausted, hold it alongside in the shade until it can swim, then let it go. Do not remove a hook from the throat or stomach. A hook left in place has a better survival rate than a torn oesophagus.

A turtle hooked in the flipper or shoulder is a different job from one hooked in the mouth. The flesh there tears, and the animal will use the injured limb to push off the boat. Support the plastron with a hand or a towel, keep the hooked limb still, cut the line close if you cannot back the hook out cleanly, and get the animal into the water rather than onto the deck. Turtles hooked where the line cannot be reached are covered in deep hook release.

What do you do with a hooked seabird?

Reel it in slowly and gently. Do not cut the line, and do not swing the bird aboard on the rod tip. Bring it over the gunwale by hand or with a net, cover its head with a towel or a soft cloth, and hold the body so the wings are folded against it. A covered bird stops struggling, which protects both the bird and your face.

Remove the hook if it is visible and the barb can be managed. The standard method is to push the hook through so the barb clears the skin, flatten or cut the barb with pliers or side cutters, and back the hook out the way it came. Do not pull a hook backwards through the flesh. If the hook is swallowed, cut the line as close as possible and leave it.

Then let the bird dry. NOAA's guidance is to keep the bird in a safe enclosed space until its feathers are dry, because a wet bird that is released too early loses buoyancy and insulation. That can take 20-30 minutes in the sun. Put it somewhere quiet, out of the wind, and check it before release.

Release it from a low point, over the stern, into clean water away from the boat and away from any gathering gulls. Do not throw it. If it does not swim away strongly, keep it and call a wildlife rescue number rather than putting it back in the water to die.

If a bird is hooked while you are trolling, stop the boat first. A bird dragged at trolling speed drowns before you reach the rod, and the wash makes the line harder to handle. Throttle back, reel in slack, and bring the bird alongside rather than through the prop wash. A bird's bill is not a handle, and a towel over the head is safer than a grip on the beak.

How a marine mammal is handled differently

The first rule is distance. NOAA recommends at least 100 yards from whales and 50 yards from dolphins, porpoises, seals and sea lions, with species-specific distances that are larger again for some populations. If you are close enough to hook a marine mammal, something has already gone wrong with your positioning or your bait.

If an animal is hooked or entangled, do not approach it, do not try to remove the gear, and do not cut the line and leave. Cut the line as short as you safely can, then move away and call the marine mammal reporting line. Large animals are dangerous, and a seal or dolphin with a hook in its mouth is not a rescue you can perform from a small boat.

Record what you saw: species or description, position, time, what gear was involved, and whether any line remains attached. That information is what allows a response team to find the animal. For a whale, the position and direction of travel matter more than anything else.

Never feed a marine mammal or use one as a marker for fish. It habituates the animal to boats, which is the root cause of most subsequent entanglements and boat strikes. The interaction you create today is the problem someone else deals with next season.

The common case is not a hooked whale. It is a sea lion or a seal taking a fish you have hooked, or sitting under the boat waiting for the next one. Do not gaff the animal, do not swing at it, and do not try to retrieve the fish. Cut the line, move a few miles, and stop fishing that mark for the day. A habituated seal will follow the boat for hours and take every fish you hook. The rules that govern a shark beside the boat are set out in shark release rules.

Which gear changes actually reduce encounters?

Circle hooks reduce deep hooking in turtles and billfish, which is why NOAA recommends them for natural bait fishing in many fisheries. A hook that sets in the corner of the mouth is a hook you can remove, and a hook you can remove is a release you can complete.

Single hooks instead of trebles reduce the number of points in a bird or a turtle, and they are easier to remove. Barbless or crimped-barb hooks are faster to take out and cause less tissue damage. If you fish lures around birds, a single inline hook is the difference between a clean release and a bird with three hooks in it.

Keep baits below the birds. Seabirds take baits at the surface and on the drop, so a bait that is fished deep with a fast sink rate is less available than one that flutters down. For trolling, a weighted lure that runs below the surface is less likely to be taken by a diving bird than a skipping surface bait.

Avoid fishing where the animals are. A turtle aggregation, a bird flock working bait, or a dolphin pod hunting is not a fishing opportunity. Move a mile and fish clean water. The bycatch you prevent is worth more than the fish you might have caught.

Timing is part of the gear choice. In shallow turtle grounds, the hours around high tide put turtles over the flats where your bait lands, and a bait fished on the bottom at dusk is the one most likely to be taken by a turtle rather than a fish. Fishing the same mark two hours earlier is a smaller change than learning to dehook a turtle.

The international seabird guidance reduces to three levers: get the bait below the surface fast, keep birds away from the gear, and fish when the birds are least active. ACAP's mitigation material for longline fleets is written for a different scale, but the levers are the same ones available on a centre console. A heavier sinker and a bait that goes down without a long surface drift prevents more hookings than any dehooker. The second lever is chum: a slick is a bird feeder, and a flock working it will follow the boat for miles and dive on every bait that touches the water. If birds are already on the slick, stop chumming and move.

What has to be reported, and to whom?

Report any hooked, entangled or injured protected animal, even if it swam away. In the US, NOAA Fisheries runs reporting lines for marine mammals and sea turtles, and some regions have species-specific hotlines, such as the Alaska SeaLife Center line for short-tailed albatross. Keep the number in your phone before you need it.

Report the interaction as it happened. Species, size, position, time, gear, hook location, whether the hook was removed or left, and the condition on release. If the animal was released with gear attached, say so and describe the gear. That is what a disentanglement team needs in order to find it.

In many countries, reporting a protected species interaction is a legal obligation, not a courtesy. In others it is voluntary but feeds into the data that decides whether recreational fishing keeps its access. Either way, an unreported interaction is invisible, and invisible interactions get managed by assumption.

Keep the tools where you can reach them: a long dehooker, side cutters, bolt cutters for heavy hooks, gloves, a towel for birds and a landing net. The kit costs less than a tank of fuel and covers every species in this article. The only thing that changes between them is whether you cut.

Have the numbers saved before the trip, not searched for with one hand while the other holds a bird. Put the national protected-species line, the local wildlife rescue and the state or regional fisheries enforcement number in the same phone folder, and write them on the boat's paperwork as a backup. A hotline that takes four minutes to find is a hotline you will not call.

If you cannot reach anyone, write it down anyway: species, size, what was hooked, where, what you did, and whether the animal swam away. The record is what a response team needs if the animal turns up later, and it is the difference between a report and a rumour.

Short version

  • Turtles and marine mammals: cut the line short and leave the hook; seabirds: never cut the line, reel the bird in and remove the hook.
  • Do not remove a hook you cannot see. Cut close to the hook and leave it in place.
  • Carry a dehooker, side cutters, bolt cutters, gloves, a towel and a net, and report every interaction with position and gear details.

Sources

  1. Fishing Tips to Protect Sea Turtles and Marine Mammals — NOAA Fisheries · T1
  2. Protected Species Workshop: Handling, Release and Identification Guidelines — NOAA Fisheries Pacific Islands Regional Office · T1
  3. Seabird Protection and Avoidance Tips — NOAA Fisheries · T1
  4. Seabird Bycatch Mitigation — Agreement on the Conservation of Albatrosses and Petrels · T1
  5. Seabird Handling Guidelines: Hawaii Pelagic Longline Fisheries — NOAA Fisheries Pacific Islands Regional Office · T1
Where the shark release answer actually lives
Drone fishing: 400 ft ceiling, but the law is the real limit
Where the no-take line actually is