Key facts
| Item | Reading |
|---|---|
| Total length | Snout to extreme tail tip |
| Fork length | Snout to tail notch |
| Texas measuring point | Extreme tip of tail fin |
| British Columbia retention floor | 30 cm |
| Adult chinook, Region 6 | Over 65 cm |
| Adult coho, Region 6 | Over 50 cm |
| Jack coho, Region 6 | 30 cm to 50 cm |
| Federal definition | 50 CFR 622.2 |
| Last federal amendment | 23 February 2026 |
The three parts of a limit
The differences between jurisdictions are less about the numbers than about which span of the fish those numbers describe. The number is the easy part. The point is the hard part, because a fish has several defensible lengths. The span from the front of the head to the farthest tip of the caudal fin is one quantity. The span from the same starting point to the notch between the lobes is another. Standard length, measured to the end of the vertebral column, is a third. They differ by the depth of a tail, and on a fast, deeply forked species that depth is not small. The method is the third part, and it is written down because the same point can be read two ways. A tail can be squeezed flat, turned sideways or left relaxed. A jaw can be closed or open. The tape can follow the body or bridge across it. Each choice moves the reading, and the rule has to pick one. Once all three parts are fixed, the limit is a quantity that two people can reproduce. That is the whole purpose: an enforcement officer and an angler standing at the same rail should arrive at the same number, or at least at numbers close enough that the margin does not matter.
How a definition enters the rulebook
The federal reef-fish rules show the mechanism. Fork length is not left to common sense; it is a defined term at 50 CFR 622.2, worded as a straight-line distance from the tip of the head to the rear centre edge of the caudal fin, with a figure in the appendix that draws the line. The source note records publication at 78 FR 22952 on 17 April 2013 and later amendments through 91 FR 8386 on 23 February 2026. That machinery matters because a defined term travels. Every limit in the part that says "fork length" inherits the appendix figure. An angler who measures to the tip of the longest lobe has measured a different quantity, and the difference is not a matter of opinion; it is the distance between two defined points. State agencies often publish the operational version rather than the statutory one. Texas puts a measurement page inside its annual regulation booklet, with a procedure rather than a definition: the fish lies on its side, the jaw is closed, a soft tail is compressed and a hard tail is turned to reach the maximum, and the reading follows a straight line to the farthest point of the tail fin. That page is guidance attached to a rule, and it tells you what the state means by the number in its table. British Columbia takes the other route. The salmon pages print the phrase directly in each limit, "from tip of nose to tail fork", so the definition and the number arrive in the same sentence. There is no separate glossary step for the angler to find.
One coast, two spans
The practical consequence is that a limit cannot be transplanted. A fish that clears a 60 cm total-length rule may fail a 60 cm fork-length rule, because the tail lobes contributed length that the notch measurement never counts. The reverse happens on square-tailed species, where an angler who hunts for a notch that is not there reads short. The two spans also interact with species shape. A deep-forked tail, such as a tuna's or a wahoo's, produces the largest gap. A rounded tail, such as a flathead's, produces almost none. A heterocercal tail, such as a sturgeon's, produces a fork that sits on the upper lobe and looks nothing like the salmon model. A rule that names a span is assuming a body plan, and the assumption is worth checking before the tape comes out. Measurement points diverge further once the animal is not a finfish. Texas publishes crab methods beside its fish method: a stone crab is read from the claw tip to the first joint behind the immovable claw, and a blue crab across the carapace from spine tip to spine tip. A lobster limit is a carapace length. Each of those is a different quantity with a different failure mode, and none of them can be checked with a fish board.
One fish, four thresholds
British Columbia's Region 6 page shows how much legal work a single span can do. All retained chinook, sockeye, pink, coho and chum must measure 30 cm or more from the tip of the nose to the tail fork. That is the retention floor. In the same region, an adult chinook is a chinook over 65 cm measured the same way, an adult coho is a coho greater than 50 cm, and a jack coho is a coho between 30 cm and 50 cm fork length. Four outcomes come from one tape. At 28 cm a coho is illegal to keep. At 45 cm it is a legal jack. At 52 cm it is a legal adult coho. A 52 cm chinook is also legal, but it remains a juvenile by the regional definition, because the chinook line is drawn at 65 cm. The tape reading in the last two cases is the same; the species and the threshold produce the difference. That structure exists because a floor and a classification line do different jobs. The floor protects immature fish from retention. The adult line sorts the catch into bag limits, retention rules and, in some areas, mark requirements. A fish can be entirely legal to keep and still belong in a different column of the count, which is why reading only the floor produces a bag that is legal in one sense and over the limit in another. The same page extends the idea to possession and season totals: a daily limit of four salmon across tidal and fresh water, a possession limit set at twice that with an eight-fish cap, and an annual limit of ten chinook over 50 cm from all fresh waters combined. Each of those is a length-qualified count, and each depends on the span being read the same way every time.
When the tape disagrees with the rule
The angler's measurement is an estimate; the officer's is the one that counts. That asymmetry is why the margin matters more than the reading. A fish that measures within a couple of centimetres of a minimum is a fish whose legal status depends on technique, and technique at a wet rail is not reliable to that tolerance. Three errors account for most of the gap. An open jaw adds length at the front. A folded or splayed tail subtracts or adds at the back. A tape that bridges the body instead of lying along it reads through the arc rather than along the fish. A sloping deck, a cooler lip or a fish that has been on ice for an hour adds its own error, and the last one always reduces the number, because a chilled fish contracts. The procedural answer is to measure before the fish goes into the box, on a flat surface, with the zero fixed at the snout. That does not make the reading perfect, but it makes it repeatable, which is what the rule is trying to achieve. The detailed technique belongs with the beginner measurement guides; the policy point here is narrower. A limit that is read to the wrong point is not a close call. It is a different rule.
Why the definitions are worth reading first
A regulation page usually gives the number, the season and the bag in the same table, and the definition sits elsewhere, sometimes in a glossary, sometimes in a different chapter. The order in which an angler reads those elements therefore matters. Number first, definition second produces a confident and sometimes wrong answer. Definition first answers a question the angler did not know to ask: which span is being priced. The three jurisdictions compared here agree on the architecture and disagree on the choices. Texas prices total length, and its guidance explains how to reach the farthest point of the tail. British Columbia prices fork length, and it states the phrase inside every limit that uses it. The federal reef-fish rules define the fork once and let every limit inherit it. All three are internally consistent, and none of them transfers cleanly to the others. The working rule is short. Find the word the limit uses, find where that word is defined, and measure that span and no other. Then treat the last two centimetres before a minimum as a release zone, because a fish that close to the line is a fish whose fate should not depend on a wet tape in a crosswind.
Related reading
Measuring a fish: total, fork and the tape that decides — the three spans explained from the angler's side, with the tape technique in full. Build a measuring board that matches the rules — how to cut a board to the definition your rule uses, rather than to the one you learned first. How to read a fishery regulation — the six elements a rule page has to state before a size number means anything. Penalties and enforcement — what happens when the number on the tape and the number in the rule disagree.
Regulations effective from 2026-09-01. Check the current local notice before you fish.
Sources
- Measurement Tips — Texas Parks and Wildlife Department · T1
- Region 6 - Skeena: Recreational salmon fishing limits, openings and closures — Fisheries and Oceans Canada, Pacific Region · T1
- 50 CFR § 622.2 - Definitions and acronyms — U.S. Government (Cornell LII reproduction) · T1
Official sources
- Texas Parks and Wildlife Department — Texas Parks and Wildlife Department · in force 2026-09-01 · accessed 2026-11-14
- Fisheries and Oceans Canada, Pacific Region — Fisheries and Oceans Canada, Pacific Region · accessed 2026-11-14
- U.S. Government (Cornell LII reproduction) — U.S. Government (Cornell LII reproduction) · in force 2026-02-23 · accessed 2026-11-14