Key facts
| Item | Rule in force | Number | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Federal finfish retention | Head and fins intact through offloading | 1 | Gulf and Caribbean EEZ |
| Onboard meal allowance | Fish parts per person aboard | 1.5 | Pounds, on a vessel equipped to cook |
| Bait piece size | Cubes or strips | 3 | 3 cubic inches, or 3 by 9 inches |
| Multi-day trip possession | Second bag after the first 24 hours | 24 | Single bag limit for a longer trip |
| Black drum, Texas | Bag and slot | 5 | 14 to 30 inches, one of the five may exceed 52 inches |
| Flounder, Texas | Bag, minimum and closure | 5 | 15 inches, closed November 1 to December 14 |
| Red snapper off Texas | Possession while fishing | 4 | State authority in federal water |
| Tuna landing | Round or eviscerated | 1 | One pectoral fin and the tail stay attached |
The five questions a fish box has to answer
Cleaning it at the reef and stacking skinless fillets is the violation. An inspection is usually an identification exercise. The officer needs to know what species are present, how long each fish is, how many there are, where they were caught and who caught them. A whole fish answers all five at once. Fillets answer none of them without paperwork, which is why the federal rule fixes the burden on the angler rather than on the officer. The requirement is not a preference for whole fish on the plate. It is the minimum information needed to apply a size limit, a bag limit and a closed season. The rule reaches the vessel and the vehicle. Section 622.10 applies to finfish in or from the Gulf EEZ and the Caribbean EEZ, and it places the duty on whoever runs a boat that fishes the EEZ: fish aboard must stay intact, and fish taken from the EEZ must stay intact through offloading ashore. A fish that is legal on the water and filleted before the dock fails that second half. A fish that is whole at the dock and filleted on the drive home is a state question after that.
What intact still allows
Intact does not mean untouched. A fish may be bled, gutted and iced, and that is how most charter crews handle a legal catch in the heat. The head stays on, the fins stay on and the skin stays on, so the fish can still be laid against a measuring board and identified by a fin ray count or a jaw line. Gutting removes the viscera, not the evidence. Bleeding removes blood, not the tail. A workable deck routine follows from that. Bleed the fish immediately, gut it if the crew prefers, then put it in an ice slurry with the head and tail out of the way of the next fish. Keep a separate bag or tub for racks when the crew is cleaning for customers, and do not let racks and fillets share a cooler without a label. At the end of the trip, the tub goes ashore with the fillets. A cooler that is organised this way takes no longer to pack and removes the argument about which fish produced which fillet. Species subparts add conditions on top of the general rule, and they are where fillet dimensions live. Section 622.10 sets no minimum fillet length; it points to subparts B through U for species-specific requirements. Where a subpart allows fillets, it typically adds a skin-retention condition or a carcass-retention condition so that the fillet can still be tied to a legal fish. The practical rule is to read the subpart for the species in the box before deciding that a fillet is acceptable.
The two exceptions
The first exception is bait. Bait is exempt from head-and-fins retention in the Gulf and Caribbean zone, and the definition is narrow: packaged headless fillets with skin attached, frozen or refrigerated; headless fillets with skin attached held in brine; or small pieces no larger than 3 cubic inches, or strips no larger than 3 inches by 9 inches, with skin attached and frozen, refrigerated or held in brine. A fish that is later sold or bought as a finfish rather than as bait does not become bait by being cut up. The second exception is a meal at sea. Legal-sized finfish kept for consumption aboard the harvesting vessel are exempt if they stay within the bag limit, if there are no more than 1.5 lb (680 g) of fish parts per person aboard, and if the vessel is equipped to cook fish on board. Three conditions, all of which have to hold. A fillet knife and a cooler do not satisfy the third one. A galley stove and a cutting board do, up to the weight cap. That third condition is the one that gets tested in practice. An officer who sees a stove, a pan and a plate of fish can apply the exception; an officer who sees a cooler of fillets and no cooking equipment cannot. The weight cap is per person aboard, not per angler fishing, so a family of four has a larger allowance than a solo trip. The bag limit still applies to the whole trip, and the exception does not permit taking extra fish on the reasoning that they will be eaten before the dock.
Bag, possession and the 24-hour clock
Section 622.11 supplies the arithmetic that decides most multi-day trips. Bag limits apply to a person on a daily basis, regardless of how many trips that person makes in a day. For a trip lasting longer than one calendar day, a person is limited to a single bag limit unless a species rule says otherwise. Possession limits, where they exist, apply after the first 24 hours of the trip. The clock starts when the trip starts, so the second morning is where the first bag becomes a possession question. The same section blocks the obvious workarounds. A person fishing the EEZ cannot stack a state allowance on top of the federal one, and no at-sea handoff cures a bag problem: fish taken under a federal limit cannot be moved to another boat at any point in the zone. The skipper of a boat fishing the EEZ is accountable for seeing that the limits are not exceeded. A pooled cooler does not create a vessel allowance; the count is still per person, and the operator carries the consequence of getting it wrong. Freezing does not suspend any of this. The bait exception names frozen and refrigerated forms because bait is expected to be stored that way; the finfish rule has no matching freezer clause. A fillet pulled from a home freezer is still a fillet without a head and fins, and a possession limit still applies to fish held ashore in some state systems. Preservation changes the texture and the evidence, not the category.
HMS keeps a different set of parts
Atlantic highly migratory species are exempt from the general head-and-fins rule and are governed by part 635 instead. Tunas must be maintained through offloading either round or eviscerated with the head and fins removed, provided one pectoral fin and the tail remain attached; the upper and lower lobes of the tail may be trimmed for storage as long as the fork stays intact. Billfish must keep the head, fins and bill intact through offloading, and may be eviscerated but otherwise must stay whole. Sharks carry the strictest attachment rule. A vessel with a federal Atlantic commercial shark permit must keep all fins, including the tail, naturally attached to the carcass until the shark is offloaded, and may remove the head and viscera but not the backbone, and may not fillet or quarter the fish aboard. A vessel with a shark endorsement must land the shark with the head, tail and all fins naturally attached; bleeding and evisceration are allowed. Swordfish must stay round or dressed through offloading. The reason for the fin rule is separate from measuring. Fins are the part of a shark most easily separated and sold, so requiring natural attachment through offloading moves the point of separation past the dock and past the scale. A sliced fin that still hangs on a strip of skin satisfies the rule for storage; a fin in a bag does not. The practical check is the same one used for finfish: if the parts needed to identify and count the fish are not attached, the fish is not in a landable condition.
The dock, the freezer and the party boat
The landing state adds its own layer. Texas asks for a licence and saltwater endorsement before a federal-caught fish can be kept inside its waters or brought ashore at a Texas ramp, and it treats possession of illegally taken federal fish as an offence in Texas water. Its bag pages then supply the numbers: black drum 5 fish per day at 14 to 30 inches, with one of the five allowed to exceed 52 inches, flounder 5 fish at 15 inches with the fishery closed from November 1 to December 14, and a general rule that the possession limit is double the bag limit unless the page says otherwise. Party boats sit in the middle of both systems. The bag limit attaches to each paying angler, not to the boat, and the operator is responsible for ensuring the vessel stays within the limits. A mate who fills one cooler for the whole charter has not created a pooled allowance; the fish still have to be countable against each passenger's bag. The workable routine is to keep each angler's fish in a separate bag or basket, label it, and leave the racks with the fish until the boat is secured.
The cooler check
Before the dock, three counts settle the whole trip. Count the fish, not the fillets. Match each fillet to a rack or to a whole fish that is still aboard. Check the trip clock against the number of days on the water. If the vessel is carrying HMS, check the part 635 condition for that species rather than the general rule, because the parts that have to stay attached are different for a tuna, a shark and a swordfish. Write the count on a tag before the ice goes in, and the numbers stop moving. State waters, which end at 3 nautical miles or 9 off Texas, run a separate rulebook, but the landing rule follows the fish ashore. A cooler that is clean, labelled and countable at the ramp is the cheapest insurance in the fishery. A cooler of skinless fillets is a conversation that starts with the length of a fish that is no longer there.
Sources
- 50 CFR 622.10 — Landing fish intact, general — U.S. Government (eCFR), NOAA · T1
- 50 CFR 622.11 — Bag and possession limits, general applicability — U.S. Government (eCFR), NOAA · T1
- 50 CFR 635.30 — Possession at sea and landing — U.S. Government (eCFR), NOAA · T1
- Drum Bag and Length Limits — Texas Parks and Wildlife Department · T1
- Flounder Bag and Length Limits — Texas Parks and Wildlife Department · T1
- Fishing in Federal Waters — Texas Parks and Wildlife Department · T1
Official sources
- U.S. Government (eCFR), NOAA — U.S. Government (eCFR), NOAA · accessed 2026-11-14
- U.S. Government (eCFR), NOAA — U.S. Government (eCFR), NOAA · accessed 2026-11-14
- U.S. Government (eCFR), NOAA — U.S. Government (eCFR), NOAA · in force 2025-08-07 · accessed 2026-11-14
- Texas Parks and Wildlife Department — Texas Parks and Wildlife Department · in force 2026-09-01 · accessed 2026-11-14
- Texas Parks and Wildlife Department — Texas Parks and Wildlife Department · in force 2026-09-01 · accessed 2026-11-14
- Texas Parks and Wildlife Department — Texas Parks and Wildlife Department · in force 2026-09-01 · accessed 2026-11-14