At a FAD, the order you hook mahi decides how many you keep

Take the medium fish first, when a mahi school is stacked under a FAD. The bull on the perimeter is the fish most likely to scatter the group before you get a second cast, and a hooked fish left in the water is what keeps the rest interested.

behavior
TargetsMahi-mahi
Watersaltwater
Regionspacific, atlantic, indo-pacific
Methodscasting, trolling, live bait
Quick answer

Take the medium mahi first when a school is stacked under a FAD. The bull on the perimeter is the fish most likely to scatter the group, and a hooked fish left in the water keeps the rest interested.

A FAD is not one school

The fish you see at the surface are rarely the whole aggregation. A fish aggregating device holds life at several depths: small mahi and skipjack near the surface, larger fish below them, and often a few adults cruising a perimeter that extends well beyond the float. NOAA Fisheries notes that juvenile mahimahi school while older fish are usually solitary, which means the tight pack under the buoy is often a young aggregation.

Size and sex structure shift as the fish grow. A review of dolphinfish biology in the western central Atlantic found that females generally outnumber males in the catch, but the ratio changes with size; a study in the Gulf of Tehuantepec found females dominant below 75 cm fork length and males predominant in the larger classes. That is why the biggest fish around a FAD is often a bull, and why the fish on the outside edge are worth a second look before you cast at the dense pack in the middle. The seamount guide covers the same current logic at a fixed feature., and why the fish on the outside edge are worth a second look before you cast at the dense pack in the middle.

Depth matters as much as position. Trolling accounts for roughly 80 percent of the catch around Hawaii FADs, according to the Hawaii Institute of Marine Biology, and trolling covers the top of the water column well. It does not cover the fish sitting 20–40 m down. A sonar mark under the school is a different opportunity from the fish you can see, and it usually calls for a live bait or a jig.

The type of FAD changes the approach. An anchored state buoy sits in one place, and the fish learn it; you can return to the same mark on the same drift. A drifting log or a fish aggregating device that has broken free moves with the current, and the school moves with it. NOAA lists drifting flotsam, anchored buoys and even dolphins among the things pelagic fish gather around, and each one behaves differently in a current. A drifting object is worth following; an anchored one is worth re-approaching from a different angle.

Read the school before the first cast

Spend two or three minutes watching before anyone casts. Look for the direction the school is moving, the size classes present, and whether the fish are spread in a loose group or packed tight under the float. A tight pack with fish flashing at the surface is a feeding school and will usually tolerate a lure. A loose group with fish cruising in different directions is a nervous school, and a boat driving into it will push the fish down and out.

Watch the current. A FAD in two knots of flow has a slack area on its down-current side and a visible disturbance line where the flow splits. Mahi often sit in the slack and dart into the current to feed, so the productive cast is often across that line. If the buoy is draped with weed, the fish may be under the weed mat.

Keep the engine noise low and the bow pointed down-current during the read. A slow drift with the engine in neutral gives you a look at the school without changing its behaviour. If the fish sound as you approach, stop and wait; mahi are curious and often come back up within a minute or two if the boat stops moving.

Colour and finning are the fastest size check. A school of small fish looks like a cloud of yellow-green flashes with a lot of surface commotion. A big bull shows a broad, dark back and a tall dorsal fin that breaks the surface, often well away from the main group. If you see one large fish and a hundred small ones, the large fish is probably the one that will spook the school; mark it, then cast away from it.

Approach at 30–50 m, and cast from the outside in

Stop 30–50 m short of the buoy and let the boat drift. That distance is a working convention, but it is far enough to avoid spooking the surface school and close enough to reach the perimeter with a normal cast. Approach from up-current when you can, so the boat drifts back toward the structure, and keep the engine in neutral so the hull moves with the same water as the fish.

The first casts go to the outside edge. Fish on the perimeter are usually less competitive and more willing to eat a moving lure, and a hook-up there does not immediately disturb the pack under the buoy. Two anglers can work opposite edges while a third keeps a live bait ready for anything that shows on the sounder. If the school is spread over 100 m, the edge may be 30 m from the float and the centre may be empty.

A drift at one knot covers about 30 m per minute, so a 20-minute drift moves the boat 600 m. Start the drift 300–500 m up-current of the FAD if you want to arrive at the structure at the right time, and plan the second pass before the first one ends. Driving back up-current under power is the fastest way to break the school's tolerance for the boat.

Which fish first: a decision by objective

If the plan is to keep fish for the table, take a medium fish first. A 60–80 cm mahi is old enough to be a real fish and young enough that removing it does not break up the group the way a big bull can. Keep it in the water beside the boat; the rest of the school often stays with a hooked fish, and that window invites a second and third cast.

If the plan is a trophy, ignore the pack and work the perimeter with a live bait or a large lure. The biggest fish is often alone or in a pair, and it is usually the least willing to compete with a crowd of small fish. A bait pitched 10–15 m outside the school, left to sink for 10–20 seconds, is a better presentation to that fish than a lure cast into the middle. The trade-off is time: the perimeter fish may take 5–10 minutes to commit, and the school may drift away while you wait.

If the plan is release, the order changes again. Take a fish quickly, keep it in the water, unhook it with pliers, and let it go without lifting it. The school stays calmer, and you get more casts. A released fish that is handled for a photograph and then dropped back into the school does more damage than a kept fish, because it flops through the group and spooks the rest.

Match the gear to the fish you are choosing. A 20–30 lb main line and a 30–40 lb leader will handle a 60–80 cm mahi without overpowering it, and a 4–6 inch live bait or a medium skirted lure is the right size for that class. If you step up to 50 lb leader for the perimeter bull, the small fish in the school may still eat, but the lure needs to be bigger and the cast shorter. Two rods rigged differently are better than one rod asked to do both jobs.

Keeping the school: chum, hooked fish and boat position

A hooked fish left in the water is the strongest attractor you have. Mahi are social and competitive, and a fish circling beside the boat pulls the school closer. Keep the first fish on a light drag, in the water, while the second angler casts. Do not gaff it in the middle of the school or lift it over the rail while fish are still visible; the disturbance is what ends the window.

A small amount of chum holds fish without feeding them. A handful of cut bait or a few live baits flicked out every minute or two keeps the school interested, but a heavy chum line pulls in skipjack, kawakawa and sharks and changes the target. If bycatch becomes the majority of the action, stop the chum and move 100–200 m away from the float to reset on the mahi.

The productive window at a single FAD is often 20–40 minutes, which is experience consensus. After that, the school either moves off or becomes educated to the boat. A second FAD 3–5 miles away is usually a better use of time than trying to force another hour out of a school that has stopped responding.

Boat position keeps the window open longer than any lure change. Keep the stern toward the school and the bow into the current, so the boat drifts away from the fish. If two anglers are casting, put one on each corner, and keep the lines at different distances so the fish are not all concentrated at one point. A school that is being caught from several directions stays confused and competitive; a school that is being chased by one angler with one lure learns the trick quickly.

When the school scatters, and what to do with bycatch

A scattered school is not a lost cause. Stop casting, put the boat in neutral, and wait 10–15 minutes. Mahi are curious, and the fish that sounded often reappear at the edge of the drift. If they do not, switch to a deep presentation: a jig or a live bait at 20–40 m under the float, where the fish that stayed deep were never disturbed.

Bycatch is part of FAD fishing. Skipjack and kawakawa are the usual companions, and they are worth keeping if the day needs bait or if the table accepts them. A shark or a wahoo taking the lure is a reason to change the leader. Check the last metre of leader after every fish, and cut back a metre if it is rough; a FAD school is a high-abrasion environment because of the buoy chain and the weed.

The decision that matters most is made before the first cast. If the objective is a trophy, fish the perimeter and accept fewer fish. If the objective is a feed, take a medium fish first, keep it in the water, and let the school do the work. The boat that drives into the middle and casts at the biggest fish gets one good look and then watches the school sink out of sight. Leaving the school alone for ten minutes usually brings it back to the same drift line, which is why the pause works better than chasing the fish that sounded.

Short version

  • Read the school for two or three minutes: size classes, spread, current and the marks under the float.
  • Stop 30–50 m off, drift with the current, and cast the outside edge before the centre.
  • Take a medium fish first and keep it in the water; target the perimeter bull only if a trophy is the objective.

Sources

  1. Pacific Mahimahi — NOAA Fisheries · T1
  2. Biology of the dolphinfish (Coryphaena hippurus) in the western central Atlantic: a review — Scientia Marina · T1
  3. Variability in relative abundance, size structure and sex ratio of the dolphinfish in the Gulf of Tehuantepec — Revista de Biología Tropical · T1
  4. FADs, a new marine debris item of concern — Hawaii Department of Land and Natural Resources · T1
  5. The FAD FAQ — Hawaii Institute of Marine Biology · T2
  6. Mahi-Mahi: Habitat, Tackle and How to Catch — Anglervale · T3
Bait Seasonality: Why the Food Chain Moves Offshore
Set Trolling Spread Geometry Before Lures
Fish Care: The First 20 Minutes Decide the Fillets