Keep the fish in the water, stop or slow the boat, wear gloves, avoid the bill, and cut the leader as close to the hook as you safely can.
Why the rule says not to lift the fish
A billfish is built to be weightless. Its skeleton, gills and internal organs are supported by water, and a 50 kg marlin hanging from its jaw by a leader is a different animal from the same fish swimming. That is why NOAA's Atlantic HMS rules say a billfish that is not being kept must be released immediately without removing it from the water, even for a picture.
The same instruction appears in ICCAT's minimum standards for safe handling: do not remove an alive marlin from the water boatside while removing the hook, limit the number of manipulations, and do not gaff the fish in the body. ICCAT wrote those rules for longline crews, but the biology does not change because the rod is in your hand.
There is a safety reason too. A green marlin at boatside swings a bill through an arc that covers most of the cockpit, and a fish dropped on deck breaks equipment and ankles. Working over the side with the fish in the water is safer for the crew as well as the fish.
So the release starts with a decision made before the bite: this fish is going back, and it is going back without coming aboard. Everything on deck should support that decision.
It helps to know what the law actually asks of you, because the recreational rules are narrower than the commercial ones. ICCAT's rebuilding programme requires member countries to make sure released fish are released in a manner that causes the least harm, sets minimum retention sizes, and bans the sale of recreationally caught marlin carcasses. Those are the binding parts. How you hold the fish is left to national guidance, which is where the NOAA instruction not to lift the fish comes from.
The gap between the two matters in practice. A crew that only reads the retention size will release a short fish by dragging it aboard for a measurement, which is legal in the narrow sense and a self-defeating way to run a release fishery. Read the handling guidance as well as the size limit.
What has to be on deck before the bite?
Four tools. A dehooker or disgorger long enough to reach a hook in a fish that is still in the water. A pair of side cutters or a line cutter that will go through mono and wire cleanly. Heavy gloves. And a measuring device that works without lifting the fish, such as a marked pole, a marked leader, or marks on the gunwale.
ICCAT's standards list the same kit for live release of marlins: a lifting device if one is needed, bolt cutters, a dehooker or disgorger, and a line cutter. The lifting device is for emergencies and for fish that must be measured for a record; it is not the default.
Mount the cutters where you can reach them without stepping over a rod. The worst version of this is a cutter in a bag under the console while a fish is thrashing at the transom. Tie them to a lanyard on the rail.
Brief the crew before the first bait goes out. One person owns the leader, one owns the cutters, one owns the camera and stays out of the way. A cockpit that agrees on roles before the bite releases fish faster and with fewer injuries than one that improvises.
Handling a fish that is still green
Slow or stop the boat first. ICCAT's guidance is explicit about stopping or substantially reducing speed before working on a fish, because a boat still making way drags the fish and loads the leader. Once the boat is out of gear, the fish settles and the leader angle comes down.
Bring the fish alongside without putting maximum pressure on the leader. A fish that is still jumping is not ready; wait for it to circle. Do not grab the bill with a bare hand, and do not put a hand near the gills. If you need to control the head, use gloves and hold the snout or a snooter, which is what ICCAT recommends.
If the hook is visible in the jaw or corner of the mouth, back it out with the dehooker while the fish is in the water. If the hook is deep or the fish is twisting too hard to work safely, cut the leader as close to the hook as you can reach and leave the hook in. A hook left in place is a better outcome than a torn jaw or a hook in a crew member's hand. Hooks that are too deep to reach are covered in deep hook release.
Do not lift the fish by the leader to pose it. If a photo matters, take it with the fish in the water, head up, hand under the jaw or on the snout. It is the same picture and a very different survival probability.
Leader handling is where most crews get hurt. Wear gloves on both hands, keep the leader on the gunwale or a cleat rather than wrapped around a hand, and never take a turn of leader around your wrist. A 50 kg fish that surges against a wrapped leader will take skin and tendon with it. If the fish turns and runs, let the leader go; the hook is already set and the fight can restart.
For a fish that is hooked in the corner of the mouth and still has energy, the cleanest outcome is often to cut the leader at the hook without touching the fish at all. You lose a hook and a short length of leader. You gain a release that took five seconds and involved no handling, which is about as good as release gets.
Where do you measure it, and why does the number matter?
Measure in the water, along the fish, from the tip of the lower jaw to the fork of the tail. That is lower jaw to fork length, the measurement used in billfish regulations. A marked pole laid alongside the fish, or marks on the gunwale read as the fish comes alongside, gets you a number without lifting it.
The numbers are not academic. ICCAT's rebuilding programme sets minimum retention lengths for recreational and sport fisheries at 251 cm lower jaw to fork for blue marlin and 168 cm for white marlin and roundscale spearfish. Anything shorter is a release, and in many jurisdictions the sale of a recreationally caught billfish carcass is prohibited outright.
For release fishing, measuring is about records and about learning. A fish that looks like a 70 kg blue marlin is often 55 kg, and a white marlin that looks small can be over the minimum. If you are fishing a tournament, measure anyway: release points usually depend on estimated length or weight, and an estimate made at the rail is more accurate than one made from memory at the dock.
Write it down before the next bait goes out. Species, estimated length, hook position, fight time and whether the hook was removed or cut. That is the data that makes you better at release, and some of it is data that fisheries managers are asking for.
If you want an estimated weight, you can get one in the water. Measure the length from the lower jaw to the fork, then the girth around the deepest part of the body, and put both into the standard length-girth formula used for billfish. It is an estimate with a wide error band, but it is a better estimate than a guess at the rail, and it gives you a number to compare across seasons without killing a fish to get it.
The one measurement that changes behaviour is the retention minimum. Once you have measured a few fish in the water, you can look at a sailfish or a white marlin alongside the boat and know, within a few centimetres, whether it is over the line. That confidence is what stops the reflex to lift a fish for a closer look.
What actually kills billfish after release
Four things, in rough order of importance. A long fight that leaves the fish exhausted and full of lactic acid. Damage from hooks in the gut or gills. Handling injuries at boatside, especially from lifting, gaffing or dropping the fish. And predation in the minutes after release, when a disoriented fish is easy prey for sharks.
NOAA's guidance attacks the first directly: use heavier tackle to shorten the fight. That is not a machismo argument, it is a survival argument. A fish brought to the boat in 15 minutes on 50 lb tackle is in better condition than the same fish after 45 minutes on 20 lb. The tackle and handling side of that is covered in catch and release.
Circle hooks address the second. NOAA recommends circle hooks and dehooking devices because they tend to hook in the jaw or corner of the mouth, where a hook can be removed cleanly. That is also why you do not strike: the hook needs the fish's turn to rotate into place.
Predation is the one anglers forget. Release the fish away from the boat rather than straight down into the shadow, and keep the boat moving slowly for a minute so the fish can orient. If sharks are already on the scene, move before you release rather than after.
Physiology explains why the clock matters. A 2016 review by Horodysky, Cooke, Graves and Brill argues that managing these fish means accounting for what happens after release rather than only what is landed, because the physiological cost of the fight and of air exposure carries into the days that follow. The practical translation is blunt: every minute out of the water adds to a debt the fish repays while it is avoiding sharks.
What do you have to report?
In the US Atlantic, recreational billfish catches and releases are reported through the HMS reporting system, and tournaments that award points for billfish must report their catches. NOAA's HMS tournament rules cover catch-and-release events as well as events that weigh fish, so a release is not a way to avoid paperwork.
At the international level, ICCAT requires its member countries to run data collection programmes in recreational and sport fisheries, including a minimum of 5 percent scientific observer coverage of blue marlin and white marlin tournaments. That coverage exists because recreational catches are a real part of the mortality budget, not a rounding error.
The practical version for a private boat is a log. Date, position, species, estimated size, hook type and position, fight time, release condition. If your country runs a reporting app, use it. If it does not, the log is still the only record you will have when a manager asks what recreational boats are catching.
Reporting also protects access. Recreational billfish fishing survives because the catches can be counted and the releases can be shown to work. A fishery that cannot demonstrate its release mortality is a fishery that gets managed by the most pessimistic assumption available.
Make the report part of the day, not a chore for later. A note on the phone at the moment of release, with the time and position attached, takes 30 seconds and is accurate. A reconstruction at the dock three weeks later is neither. If the country you fish in has an app, the app does this for you; if it does not, the note is the record.
One more number is worth keeping: the release condition. Swimming away strongly, swimming away slowly, or revived alongside before release. Those three categories turn a catch log into a survival log, and survival is the number that decides whether a release fishery is doing what it claims.
Short version
- Release without lifting the fish; NOAA and ICCAT both say keep it in the water, even for a photo.
- Stop the boat, wear gloves, stay away from the bill, and cut the leader close if the hook will not back out cleanly.
- Measure in the water: 251 cm LJFL for blue marlin and 168 cm for white marlin are the ICCAT retention minimums.
- Shorten the fight with heavier tackle, use circle hooks, and log every release.
Sources
- Recommendation by ICCAT to Establish Rebuilding Programs for Blue Marlin and White Marlin/Roundscale Spearfish (Rec. 19-05) — International Commission for the Conservation of Atlantic Tunas · T1
- HMS Compliance Guide: Recreational Fishing Guide for Atlantic Tunas, Swordfish, Shark and Billfish Regulations — NOAA Fisheries, Atlantic Highly Migratory Species Management Division · T1
- Careful Catch and Release Brochure — NOAA Fisheries · T1
- Fisheries conservation on the high seas: linking conservation physiology and fisheries ecology for the management of large pelagic fishes — Conservation Physiology · T1
- IGFA International Angling Rules — International Game Fish Association · T2